All of the fan fictions will have a rating, unless no one rated it. This has happened for some fan fictions, but most have a rating. The ratings are as follows:
The ratings are collected from those that have read the fan fiction and averaged out. If you have commented on any fan fiction that is indexed here, you are on my list to supply a rating. If you wish to be removed from the list, all you have to do is shoot me a PM. New ratings are collected once every year. As not everyone supplies a new rating, the old ones will also carry over unless the reader changes them with a new one.
It should be noted that individual authors can attain a rating based on their fan fiction(s). A fan fiction will only contribute to its author's rating if it has more than two votes.

Note: The rating system used to be 1-5. As not everyone supplies a new vote, some votes have been converted to 1-10. Most have been replaced with new votes.

There are ratings and statuses for fan fictions. Beneath the rating will be the status. The statuses are as follows:
Below the status will be a description. If you would like to provide a description for something you have created, please PM it to me/post it here and I'll put it in. Some descriptions are by me on fan fictions I have read. If you (as the author) wish these removed, let me know.

Those authors that have placed in the fan fic contest over 3 times (see Contests, below) have a 'Competitive Rating.' This rating is additional and separate from the standard rating. The ratings are as follows, from best to worst:
The lower the number, the better the author.

Akralon (1)
Rating: 8.7

AMIS (1)
Rating: 8
Competitive: 2.17

AnubianWolf88 (1)
Rating: 8

Araaz Grimm (1)
Rating: 6
Competitive: 2.4

BassistofDoom (1)
Rating: Pending
Competitive: 2.46

BiggaBullfrog (0)
Rating: N/A
Competitive: 1.5 (Competitive Fan Fiction Expert)

Bro-Man (2)
Rating: 7.2
Competitive: 2.4

Bumper15 (1)
Rating: 10
Competitive: 2.18

Chardar (1)
Rating: 7.25

Crixus33 (0)
Rating: N/A
Competitive: 2.3

Dandnarg434 (1)
Rating: 7.8
Competitive: 2.0

Darconus (3)
Rating: 9.7

The Deadliest Warrior (5)
Rating: 7.79

Dragonfire9788 (1)
Rating: 8
Competitive: 2.8

Dysole (0)
Rating: N/A
Competitive: 1.89 (Competitive Fan Fiction Expert)

Elsinora (1)
Rating: 8.33

Elven Lord (4)
Rating: 6.6
Competitive: 3.18

Fi Skirata (1)
Rating: Not Available

The Grim Reaper's Friend (10)
Rating: 8.94
Competitive: 2.07

Gold1 (1)
Rating: 6

Gorthan313 (1)
Rating: 8

Horde Lorde (1)
Rating: Not Available

Jhonny139 (1)
Rating: Not Available

Keetacongoo (1)
Rating: 7

Knight of Scape (1)
Rating: 7.4

Machinekng (1)
Rating: 8

Majora's Incarnation (1)
Rating: 8

Marro_Warlord (3)
Rating: Pending

Metaknight (2)
Rating: 7.8

Mysterium (1)
Rating: 8

Orcs Blade (3)
Rating: 8.2
Competitive: 2.33

Pumpkin_King (4)
Rating: 8

TheAverageFan (1)
Rating: Pending
Competitive: 1.00 (Competitive Fan Fiction Champion)

The Scaped (1)
Rating: 10

S1R ART0R1US (1)
Rating: Not Available

Son of Arathorn (1)
Rating: 8
Competitive: 1.88 (Competitive Fan Fiction Expert)

Sylvano (1)
Rating: Not Available

Tornado (1)
Rating: 8
Competitive: 2.67 (Fan Fiction Prompt Master)

wk4c (1)
Rating: Pending

All slaves are equal, a tale of the vipers by Knight of Scape
Rating: 7.3
Status: Not Active
Votes: 10
Description: Although it is supposed to be mainly about the vipers, so far, this fan fiction has followed a young marro by the name of Ne-Gok. (Wonder who it could be?) A powerful marro has recently put him and other marro through a series of tests, and Ne-Gok is the only one to pass them all. Now he is training under his new master, but outside his life war is stirring...

Appocalypse: Valhalla's Darkest Hour by The Grim Reaper's Friend (Silver Author)
Rating: 8
Status: Completed
Votes: 3
Description: The Infected, horrible zombie-marro mutants, have spread across Valhalla. Unable to stop the unending hordes, those that have survived have fled to Haukeland. Now, with a faint ray of hope at ending the apocalypse, a small group of warriors has been sent back into the heart of Infected territory. Success is critical, but certain members within the group have their own plans for this mission...

Battles of Valhalla by Bro-man
Rating: 7
Status: Completed (Compilation)
Votes: 5
Description: In Battles of Valhalla, Bro-Man has several fan fics, each as good as the last. An excellent writer, he brings the battles of Valhalla to life. Be sure to check his thread out.

The Black Necromancer by mysterium
Rating: 8
Status: Not Active
Votes: 2
Description: Not Available

Bloodlines by Bro-man
Rating: 7.33
Status: Not Active
Votes: 3
Description: The story follows the Airborne soldier named Jake. He tends to work alone and is called the lone wolf by some. One day he is taken to help find his missing friends. However, his path leads him to something startling. Soon, his actions will decide the fate of an entire race.
Reviews:
"Interesting and intriguing." ~TheAverageFan
"The suspense and mystery are killing me!" ~The Grim Reaper's Friend

Ceasefire by Gold1
Rating: 6
Status: Not Active
Votes: 3
Description: Not Available

Code 4114 by The Grim Reaper's Friend (Silver Author)
Rating: N/A
Votes: 0
Status: Being Written
Description: Dan Beorm is a rebel from the prison moon of Isadora. Summoned from a struggle that is his life, bound to a general he distrusts, and sent on a mission that could end a war that is not his to end, Dan will have to face many obstacles if he is to prevail against all the foes Alpha Prime, Valhalla, and other, less known worlds, can throw at him. He may be able to come out alive, but can he escape destruction and change of a different sort? Find out in the massive Code 4114.
Indexer's Note: This will be a rewrite of the Quest for Valhalla, the Last Battles of the Valkyrie, and new unreleased material concerning Dan Beorm.
Removal Chance: 25%

The Company of the Adder (Story of Slink) by Elven Lord
Rating: 6.33
Status: Completed.
Votes: 3
Description: Slink, a Naga character from the Prison Faction, proves to make an excellent hero. Elven Lord delves deeply into Slink's surroundings and Naga culture, painting a vivid picture with his words. Slink and several others are led together by certain gods to form a group called the 'Adder'. They have been given their first mission, now their only trouble is carrying it out, although dispute over leadership has already arisen...
Reviews:
"Fantastic pieces, can't wait for more." ~bumper15
"Great story!" ~Orcs Blade

Crawl Through the Dungeon by dragonfire9788
Rating: 8
Status: On Hold
Votes: 1
Description: Not Available

Curse of the White Cross by Elven Lord
Rating: 6.5
Status: Not Active
Votes: 4
Description: Not Available
Indexer's Note: Previously titled "Fallen World."

Dragon Den Adventure by S1R ART0R1US
Rating: Not Available
Status: Downloadable
Votes: 0
Description: Not Available

The Fall of Valhalla by Darconus
Rating: 9
Status: Completed
Votes: 2
Description: Not Available
Indexer's Note: There is a prequel to this: the Trials of Syvarris, below.

The Final Battleground by The Grim Reaper's Friend (Silver Author)
Rating: 9.6
Status: Completed.
Votes: 5
Description: My first zombie story, this fan fiction documents the rise of zombies on earth, through dark means. Soon, all of earth is contaminated, and no one is safe. Only a select few remain to struggle on for humanity. Will they succeed in wiping out every last zombie? Or will they fall prey to the sheer numbers of their foes? Find out in the Final Battleground.
Removal Chance: 15%

The Flag Bearer Wars by Darconus
Rating: 10
Status: Not Active
Votes: 1
Description: Not Available
Indexer's Note: Sequel to the Fall of Valhalla, above.

The Gene Chronicles by Fi Skirata
Rating: Not Available
Status: Not Active
Votes: 0
Description: Not available

Good Morning Valhalla by Akralon (Bronze Author)
Rating: 8.73
Status: Not Active
Votes: 15
Description: Akralon has come with the new idea of a radio talk-show for HeroScape in this thread. A series of interviews, each with a different HeroScape character is posted. The character is asked questions which have been suggested by the audience (other posters) and (sometimes) gives answers. Akralon has incorporated humor into this thread, making it a fun place to check out.

Gorthan's Scape Fics by gorthan313
Rating: 8
Status: Not Active
Votes: 1
Description: Not Available

Grey by The Deadliest Warrior
Rating: 2
Status: Not Active
Votes: 1
Description: Not Available

Having a Marvelous Time by Pumpkin_King
Rating: Pending
Status: Completed
Votes: 0
Description: Chaos reigns and steampunkery rules when ten Marvel heroes find themselves in Valhalla. Why are they here? They don't know, but the villains are sure going to make the most of it. (From fanfiction.net)
Reviews: "You have to be the only person on here who can effectively mix Heroscape and Marvelscape. Well done, like always." ~Keetacongoo

The Heart of Vengeance by the Grim Reaper's Friend (Silver Author)
Rating: 8.5
Status: Completed
Votes: 3
Description: Revenge for the murder of his father may come at a high price, but it is one Ragnak is willing to pay. Anything to slay Grimnak, champion of Theranock. Only once he has had his vengeance, will he be able to once again have peace. Only then will he be able to live again. The price may have been too high, however, and Ragnak's new life might not be as peaceful as he had imagined... if indeed it ever comes.
Reviews:
"Great stuff... way cool." ~Hendal
Removal Chance: 5%

Home. by Chardar
Rating: 7.25
Status: Not Active
Votes: 4
Description: Not Available
Reviews:
"This is great!" ~IHateAtlaga
"Feels real professional! ~DrummerScaper97

HULK SMASH VYDAR! by Pumpkin King
Rating: 8
Status: Completed
Votes: 1
Description: Not Available, though I believe the title is fairly straight forward.

Indiana Jones and the Wizards of the Coast by The Deadliest Warrior
Rating: 8.08
Status: Completed
Votes: 12
Description: The Quest is on to save HeroScape! The evil forces of the Wizards of the Coast are hunting down all HeroScape figures, and it is up to Indy to stop them, with help from some HeroScapers along the way. One of the best fictions I've read, I would highly recommend this. It is funny, short, and very well written.
Reviews:
"Great story." ~Kaiser Cat
"An epic interpretation of our little world." ~bumper15

Johnny's One-Off Fan-Fics by Johnny139
Rating: Not Available
Status: Completed (Compilation)
Votes: 0
Description: Not Available

Journey of the Elves by Horde Lorde
Rating: Not Available
Status: Not Active
Votes: 0
Description: Not Available

To Kill A Marro Drone by Keetacongoo
Rating: 4
Status: Not Active
Votes: 1
Description: Not Available

Kingdom Hearts: Brilliant Rise by Majora's Incarnation
Rating: 7
Status: Not Active
Votes: 1
Description: Not Available

Kit: Young Ninja by Orcs Blade
Rating: 8
Status: Completed
Votes: 5
Description: In Kit: Young Ninja, Orcs Blade turns out an incredibly engaging and well-written fan fic. Orcs Blade masterfully relates how Kit's friend, Derrick, is banished from their village. Determined to stay with his friend, Kit starts out after Derrick, but soon discovers that more is happening than he suspected. Full of humor and engagingness, Orcs Blade has written this fan fic in short chapters, making it easier to read. The best part of it all is that there is a sequel to it, Vengeance.

The Land of Shadow by Orcs Blade
Rating: Not Available
Status: On Hold
Votes: 0
Description: I have not read much of this, but Orcs Blade has begun a fan fiction about the MTG world of Innistrad. Anything on Innistrad is bound to be interesting, and coming from an author like Orcs Blade, well written and engaging as well. Be sure to check it out.

The Last Battles of the Valkyrie by the Grim Reaper's Friend (Silver Author)
Rating: 8.75
Status: Completed
Votes: 4
Description: Book two in the Last Battles of Valhalla series! Dan and his friends continue their journeys, but meanwhile, the evil Utgar is destroying all who oppose him. Soon, only one remains, gathering an army to defeat him. But he is deep within the Thaelink. Will he prevail over the evil general? Or will Utgar forever hold Valhalla in his grasp? Find out in the Last Battles of the Valkyrie!
Removal Chance: 0%

Learos by AMIS
Rating: 8
Status: Completed
Votes: 1
Description: Not Available

A New Marr by Metaknight
Rating: 8
Status: Completed
Votes: 1
Description: Not Available

A New Marr: Book 2 by MetaKnight
Rating: 7.6
Status: Not Active
Votes: 5
Description: Not Available

The Price of Un-life by Araaz Grimm
Rating: 6
Status: Not Active
Votes: 1
Description: Not Available

The Quest for Valhalla by the Grim Reaper's Friend (Silver Author)
Rating: 9.17
Status: Completed
Votes: 6
Description: In this first installment in the Last Battles of Valhalla series, follow a group of four heroes as they are summoned from their native worlds and are soon sent on a vital mission. Their success could mean the end of the war, but danger lurks at every turn. Will they be able to defeat the forces of the Underdark and Valkrill himself?
Removal Chance: 0%

The Rise and Fall of the Pumpkin King by (surprisingly enough) Pumpkin King
Rating: Not Available
Status: Completed
Votes: 0
Description: Not Available

The Rise of Hel by Dadnarg434
Rating: 7.8
Status: Not Active
Votes: 5
Description: Dadnarg434 has come out with one of the best fan fics I have read in the Rise of Hel. Utgar, deciding to crush the alliance once and for all, summons a goddess. Unfortunately, something appears to go wrong with the summoning, and the goddess Hel emerges as a terrifying dragon-like beast. After Utgar has sent the new terror on its mission of destruction, the havoc it wrecks seems unstoppable. With nearly unlimited power, is there anyone who can stand in the way of the mighty Hel?

The River that was Red by the Grim Reaper's Friend
Rating: 8.5
Status: Completed
Votes: 2
Description: After her life is destroyed by Utgar's armies, Raelin tries desperately to stop the war raging across Valhalla. She is opposed at every turn, and evidence only builds that the war will never end. It soon becomes apparent that Raelin's actions will either end the war... or result in one of the largest bloodbaths of history.
Author's Note: Some scenes may be briefly graphic - see in-thread author's note for full details.
Removal Chance: 15%

Sir Fellswain Voldaren by Elven Lord
Rating: Not Available
Status: Not Active
Votes: 0
Description: Not Available

Soul of Calradia by Elven Lord
Rating: Pending
Status: Not Active
Votes: 0
Description: Not Available

Tales of Eslo by Tornado
Rating: 7.5
Status: Completed (Compilation)
Votes: 1
Description: Eslo, a new character, proves to be the hero of a very good fiction. Eslo is unlike most other fan fic characters, and therefore proves to add an interesting and engaging element to the ever growing collection of fan fiction. Be sure to look at this and tell Tornado what you think.

ThunderStorm by TheAverageFan
Rating: Pending
Status: Completed and Downloadable
Votes: 0
Description: This recording of a Massive Campaign Scenario tells the story of the unlikely hero Brandis Skyhunter uniting a nation to battle the evil usurper Othkurik and his eight Guardians.
Indexer's Note: This fiction is a PDF.

The Trials of Syvarris by Darconus
Rating: 10
Status: Completed
Votes: 1
Description: Not Available
Indexer's Note: Prequel to the Fall of Valhalla, above.

To Walk the Halls of Fear by the Grim Reaper's Friend (Silver Author)
Rating: Pending
Status: Completed
Votes: 0
Description: Linia wakes in a strange room, her memories gone. With only Mark - an equally mind-wiped agent - to help her, she must attempt to escape the strange place they find themselves in. But something is very wrong with this place, very wrong indeed...

Underground by The Deadliest Warrior
Rating: 7
Status: Completed
Votes: 4
Description: Not Available

Untitled by Son of Arathorn
Rating: 8
Status: On Hold
Votes: 1
Description: Well, the title may not be the best, but this fan fiction of SoA's is just as good, if not better than the Rise of Hel, sadly never completed. It ground to a halt after a few chapters, which left all of its readers hanging, if I recall correctly. Utgar has unleashed a new, deadly horror upon his enemies. Will the alliance survive, or will they be gobbled up by the unknown beasts that now roam Valhalla?

Valhalla: After the End by machinekng
Rating: 8
Status: Special (Being restarted)
Votes: 2
Description: The great war has come to a close, but now a new war has arisen. A war of politics, as the generals of the victorious alliance try to piece together the remnants of the shattered land of Valhalla.

Valhalla Reborn (Original) by the Grim Reaper's Friend (Silver Author)
Rating: 8.4
Status: Completed
Votes: 5
Description: Valhalla Reborn follows the tale of Syvarris and Thorgrim, two fast friends, after the evil forces of Valkrill have taken over Valhalla. They soon discover that a new power is on the rise, one far more powerful than Valkrill. Will they be able to stop this power and save all of Valhalla? Or will the tyranny of the land simply change hands? Find out in Valhalla Reborn.
Indexer's Note: This fan fiction was only completed recently. There is a multi-year long gap in the middle. The first half of it is very similar to the second half of Valhalla Reborn, below. However, the two fan fictions are in no way connected.
Removal Chance: 0%

Valhalla Reborn (LBV) by the Grim Reaper's Friend (Silver Author)
Rating: 9.67
Status: Completed
Votes: 3
Description: The Last Battles of Valhalla Series comes to an end in this third and final book, Valhalla Reborn. After the final battle of the Valkyrie of Valhalla, evil still broods over the land. The marro, nearly wiped out by a deadly fire, have risen once again, now more dangerous than ever before. It falls to a lone survivor, Thorgrim, to end Utgar's tyranny once and for all. But the odds are overwhelmingly against him. Will he succeed? Find out in Valhalla Reborn!
Removal Chance: 0%

Valhalla: Hall of the Slain by The Scaped
Rating: 10
Status: Completed. Side story not completed.
Votes: 2
Description: Not Available

Vengeance by Orcs Blade
Rating: 8.33
Status: On Hold
Votes: 6
Description: The hunt for Cyprien is on in the sequel to Kit: Young Ninja! Kit has been searching for Cyprien for months, and now, with the help of Daniel, a Krav Maga Agent, he is on his way to confront him. Be sure to not miss this great fiction!

Welcome to Valhalla by The Deadliest Warrior
Rating: 7.75
Status: Not Active. Individual stories Completed.
Votes: 4
Description: Not Available

The Wind in the Trees by Bumper15 (Gold Author)
Rating: 9.25
Status: completed
Votes: 4
Description: The Wind in the Trees relates the adventures of a woodsprite by the name of Orin. Bumper15 masterfully follows him through his journeys as he meets briefly with Elven Lord's character, Slink, battles the evil Necromancer, and is summoned to Valhalla to fight for Ullar. Exciting new developments occur nearly every chapter in this incredible fan fiction, The Wind in the Trees. Be sure to have a look.
Indexer's Note: Orin was created in the Prison Faction (see below) and it is there that his adventures are concluded.

Zombies - The End by BassistofDoom
Rating: Pending
Status: Completed
Votes: 0
Description Not Available

The Adventures of Concan by Marro_Warlord
Rating: 6
Votes: 1

The End of the Road by AnubianWolf88
Rating: 8
Votes: 1

The Goodbye. by Pumpkin King
Rating: 8
Votes: 2

A Heroscape Christmas by Sylvano the Wasabus
Rating: 9
Votes: 1
Reviews:
"Awesome! Sylvano! Awesome!" ~ZBeeblebrox
"Excellent story!!" ~bumper15

How Armies Are Made: A Short Story by keetacongoo
Rating: 10
Votes: 2

The Promise by Elsinora
Rating: 8.33
Votes: 3
Reviews:
"You have quite a gift for words." ~TGRF.

A Quality of Mercy by the Deadliest Warrior
Rating: 8.33
Votes: 3
Reviews:
"A highly masterful bit of writing." ~TGRF.
"Very powerful and quite well done!!" ~William099