The Book of Beta Ray Bill

[marrowick]

Hi guys. I'm back now. I see no one has posted in the thread since my last post but I really need some more feedback on what we want to change since I posted a new idea.

[Yodaking]

Since no one seems to feel very strongly one way or the other, just post the updated stats you want tested and make a proposal for the changes you want. With no changes to the power set, just the base stats, the proposal should go pretty smoothly. Then maybe we can get a test or two with the updated stats and wrap this one up. Also add the last two set of tests to the FP so anyone voting on your proposal can take a quick look over the most recent test results.

[marrowick]

Originally Posted by Yodaking

Since no one seems to feel very strongly one way or the other, just post the updated stats you want tested and make a proposal for the changes you want. With no changes to the power set, just the base stats, the proposal should go pretty smoothly. Then maybe we can get a test or two with the updated stats and wrap this one up. Also add the last two set of tests to the FP so anyone voting on your proposal can take a quick look over the most recent test results.

Okay. I just want some clarification what the proposel is. A vote from the heroes or a post in the Playtesting thread?

[Yodaking]

Just make a post in this thread that says, I propose we update BRB base stats to ........ and run a few more tests at ____ points. Put the proposal part in bold and let the heroes vote yea or nay. Might want to do the @ thing for each voting hero in the post to make sure they are aware of the proposal as this thread has not seen much activity in quite a while.

[marrowick]

Originally Posted by Yodaking

Just make a post in this thread that says, I propose we update BRB base stats to ........ and run a few more tests at ____ points. Put the proposal part in bold and let the heroes vote yea or nay. Might want to do the @ thing for each voting hero in the post to make sure they are aware of the proposal as this thread has not seen much activity in quite a while.

Okay thanks.

@A3n @IAmBatman @johnny139 @quozl @SirGalahad @tcglkn @TrollBrute . I propose a vote to playtest Beta Ray Bill with 8 Life and 8 Attack.

A3n = nay
IAmBatman =
johnny139 = yea
quozl = yea
SirGalahad = yea
Tcglkn =
Trollbrute =

[SirGalahad]

yea

[quozl]

Yea

[johnny139]

I'm assuming this is the same draft in general in the Second Post, except for the Life/Attack changes?

If so, Yea.

[marrowick]

Originally Posted by johnny139

I'm assuming this is the same draft in general in the Second Post, except for the Life/Attack changes?

If so, Yea.

Yes it is. The stat changes proposed in my post are the only changes to his design that I am currently proposing.

[A3n]

Nay - I think with B2B it's too much. I think that attacking with an Asgardian which have large attacks by themselves then attacking with another large attacker is too much this design has me a little worried. I'd probably be fine with the life to 8 but not an attack of 8 as well.

[Yodaking]

Originally Posted by A3n

Nay - I think with B2B it's too much. I think that attacking with an Asgardian which have large attacks by themselves then attacking with another large attacker is too much this design has me a little worried. I'd probably be fine with the life to 8 but not an attack of 8 as well.

I thought the same thing, until I tested the design. Perhaps I didn't play it the right way but I found it hard to set up and execute. It seems so simple, OM1 on Asgardian who flies adj. to a figure, OM2 on BRB who flies adj. to Thor and the opponents figure, OM3 on Asgardian who also gives you an attack with BRB, but for some reason is just doesn't play out like that.

[TrollBrute]

I prefer 7 Attack as well. I'm not worried about it being too strong, but it should keep the cost from going above Thor's and I feel like 8/6/1/7/7 is a good spot for him.