The Book of Green Arrow (Oliver Queen) (Justice League)

[Lord Pyre]

Sounds fine to me!

[tcglkn]

Yea, fine with 210 based on the last test.

[johnny139]

Wording stuff all looks good to me - should be all set for carding if Karat doesn't have anything.

I will note again that I'd lean toward the "Robin Hood" look for the figure - third one linked in the SP and more iconically Justice League-y. But Nobody's also works, though that is the only Golden/Silver age figure we have for the character. The hooded one sort of says "I do not like the Justice League and am off doing my own thing for the little guy," which just doesn't seem to match the design. Not a dealbreaker but it does seem sensible to try and match things up.

Also, I know we try to do "flying towards the camera" type comic art for JL designs. Not sure if we still want to stick with that aesthetic?

[IAmBatman]

Yeah, I agree with leaving the hooded look for a more solo "Longbow Hunters" type of design.

[Arch-vile]

I mean, the hooded costume has been the classic Green Arrow look for over a decade. All the modern shows, games, and comics use it, and everything I've seen has Green Arrow as a main leaguer.

[IAmBatman]

Not a deal-breaker for me. Just feels like a Silver Agey design.

But maybe we save that look for a more "trick arrow"/"Arrowcar" kinda approach.

[johnny139]

Originally Posted by Arch-vile

I mean, the hooded costume has been the classic Green Arrow look for over a decade. All the modern shows, games, and comics use it, and everything I've seen has Green Arrow as a main leaguer.

Outside the comics, yeah, that's his new default. But in the comics, there's only four "hooded costume" eras:

1987-1993 - The "Longbow Hunters" era. Low tech, low powers. Ollie is not a JL member, the JL does not interact with him. It's intentionally its own thing.
2006-2009 - The "One Year Later" era. Mayor of Star City, marries Black Canary. Not a JL member, but on good terms with them, with Dinah and Roy as members.
2009-2011 - The "Brightest Day" era. This is after Cry for Justice, where he's on the run after killing Prometheus. Very much not a JL era for him.
2016-2020 - The "Rebirth" era. New continuity, actively anti-JL verstion of Ollie. It's a regular plot point that he dislikes and distrusts the League.

So there's only a few years where he's rocking the hood and hanging out with the JL.

It's not a huge deal - he does do it a bunch of universes and continuities, like you said - but as a Green Arrow guy, it would be weird for our "standalone" version to be wearing his Justice League costume and his "Justice League" version to be wearing his standalone costume.

[LordVenoc]

He's got the Hood in New 52. It isn't consistently up, but he has it, and does have it up frequently. This is also the era where he led Justice League United.

I just don't like using the very obviously Silver Agey one here.

Personally I'd say this one fits the best:

[Arkham]

Personally, it feels a bit like

territory. Fine with whatever though. Have the card ready whenever that all is decided.

[MrNobody]

To me, it just feels like a matter of time until the hood look is given to an incarnation of him that is in the "real" League.

[Arch-vile]

Sounds like no one has a super strong opinion and everyone prefers a different option anyway.

Let's stick with the hood. Might want to wait for Karat's wording edits Ark, in case he has any.

[Lord Pyre]

I mean, I like to be as accurate as possible, but if it's a case of pretty darn close, I'm not too worried.

Also I've always used the hooded mini in the OP.