The Book of Uprooted Tree

[IAmBatman]

I mean, I'm in favor, but that doesn't mean it's happened.

[Tornado]

Everything. Everywhere. All at once.

[IAmBatman]

That looks good, right?

[quozl]

Originally Posted by Dr. Jekyll

Wouldn't all current trees be huge anyway?
Correct, which has not happened yet. Hoping this will help with that.
They shouldn't replace the trees until they are moved.
This design was written up before the big throwing rules change so there may be some issues with this wording.
I could just remove that last sentence and it should be fine. You would just roll attack dice for a large DO being thrown instead of a huge DO like the trees.

Yes.
Cool.
Right, and throwing them moves them.
Yeah, I think just removing that line is best.

[Dr. Jekyll]

Originally Posted by quozl

Yes.
Cool.
Right, and throwing them moves them.
Yeah, I think just removing that line is best.

SP updated.

[quozl]

Yea

[Alexandros]

My apologies.

Like Tornado, I assumed that we were testing as though evergreen trees were being resized.

Somewhat conveniently, we were throwing around the largest evergreen tree in all but one instance, which I had thought was huge. In each of those instances, three or more skulls were rolled. In theory, these could have been trees of death and it would not have made a difference as they would still produce uprooted trees.

I'll make sure to get better info next time.

[IAmBatman]

It probably could’ve been clearer. No worries.

[tcglkn]

For the record, officially this shouldn't have even been tested with the DO throwing rules, but this does seem like a case where I would have made an exception there to get more trees moved around.

[Alexandros]

Originally Posted by tcglkn

For the record, officially this shouldn't have even been tested with the DO throwing rules, but this does seem like a case where I would have made an exception there to get more trees moved around.

Understood. If absolutely necessary, I could try to get another test game in. I was told that it would be great if I could play at least one of the tests with TDO rules. It seems like there are a lot of elements at play in this design that make communication about testing this awkward.

[tcglkn]

Originally Posted by Alexandros

Understood. If absolutely necessary, I could try to get another test game in. I was instructed to play at least one of the tests with TDO rules. It seems like there are a lot of elements at play in this design that make communication about testing this awkward.

Like I said not a big deal and definitely support it being used here so I am glad it was suggested. Just making sure you were aware those were not allowed in standard testing since it seemed like you were using them. Not saying you did anything truly wrong in that case.

[Dr. Jekyll]

Originally Posted by Alexandros

Understood. If absolutely necessary, I could try to get another test game in. I was told that it would be great if I could play at least one of the tests with TDO rules. It seems like there are a lot of elements at play in this design that make communication about testing this awkward.

No worries here, no need for more testing. I suggested the Throwing rules because this was designed around using the Throwing rules.

The design itself suggests that you can throw Evergreens with its wording.
I should have clarified more, and for that, I apologize. You gave some good tests here, no need to worry and I'm glad you enjoyed them.