Who is #1 and who is not? - Page 4

1Mmirg · #37 August 4th, 2009, 05:58 PM

A few (likely very obvious) thoughts:

I'd take...

Krug ... if it were largely punch for punch (esp. if points count in some way)
Q9 ... if Range were particularly important
Nilfheim ... if flying were particularly important
Kaemon Awa ... if being single-spaced and ranged were important
Cyprien ... if being single-spaced and flying were important

TheLorax · #38 August 5th, 2009, 12:47 AM

As others have mentioned, I think the match up calculator is a toe-to-toe, blow-for-blow scenario that assumes the units will have roughly the same number of turns and no height advantage.

Also, I am surprised no one has mentioned Braxis. At 8 life, the ability to fly, and an ability like Sudema's, she is a definite contender. However the large and huge heroes would be safe.

I'd stand by Q9 if it were to be a "best of" or swiss style or round-robin match up. His soulborg largeness is just so safe.

KCU Master 2007 · #39 August 5th, 2009, 01:21 AM

Nilfheim would be my star contender. As several people can attest too, I love that big ol' Ice dragon, perhaps more than I should.

Just wish he wasn't so finicky for me.

donjake · #40 August 5th, 2009, 05:57 PM

Its all up to opinion and the scenario. I personal love Syvarris and Sargent drake but squads like Airborne Elites and Tarn viking warriors are up there.

majorQ13 · #41 August 6th, 2009, 10:15 PM

PErsonally you guys are forgetting Torkulna the best marro ever

Kroc · #42 August 11th, 2009, 03:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1Mmirg

Krug ... if it were largely punch for punch (esp. if points count in some way)
Q9 ... if Range were particularly important
Nilfheim ... if flying were particularly important
Kaemon Awa ... if being single-spaced and ranged were important
Cyprien ... if being single-spaced and flying were important

After posting I especially thought Q9 was probably better if you had to consider range. I think if we get into flying being important then we are really not looking for the best 1v1 figure, but that's just me. Personally I'd take Krug if he can get toe-to-toe, and Q9 if he can ride his range.

Quote:

Originally Posted by majorQ13

PErsonally you guys are forgetting Torkulna the best marro ever

Krug beats Tor-kul-na 78.467% of the time.
Krug beats Braxis 14.483% of the time. (someone elses's suggestion).

Doe Braxis win? I don't care enough to go through all of the matchups. I still have to stand in awe of Krug's ability to smack down many times his weight in points. KRUG SMASH! ME LOVE KRUG!

JD_TigerGuy · #43 August 13th, 2009, 10:05 PM

What about Su-Bak-Na??? he is cheaper than Jotun and can Fly. I like Nilfheim too, but to exspensive for a 600 point game.

Bonecrusher · #44 August 13th, 2009, 10:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kroc

Krug beats Braxis 14.483% of the time. (someone elses's suggestion).

Doe Braxis win? I don't care enough to go through all of the matchups. I still have to stand in awe of Krug's ability to smack down many times his weight in points. KRUG SMASH! ME LOVE KRUG!

You take away PAB and this is what you get.