C3G holds a fan vote on a regular basis to determine units to be designed in public, known as the Public Design. When a the previous winner of this thread hits Public Playtesting, we will begin taking nominations for the next Public Design in this thread.
This thread is open to everyone to nominate or vote, not just official C3G members. Let us know what you want to see!
How do I nominate a design?
When nominations are open for an upcoming round of voting, anyone may nominate a single design by posting a link to the design. The best place to find designs is the Public Design Workshop. Any design from a C3G Hero (past or present), Sidekick, or Ally is valid for nomination so long as the designer has completed at least one public playtest* between the announcement of the most recent winner of this poll and the closing of first round nominations. You may not nominate your own design, spread the love. :)
After the Heroes have approved the nominations, voting will begin! Voting will occur in a single-elimination bracket. Everyone can vote, whether they are a member of C3G or not.
Once the final round of voting concludes, the winner will be decided! The designer may immediately begin a new design thread for that unit. Designs created through Public Design Nominations do not cost any Reward Points.
Spider-Man (Symbiote Suit) First place votes: 2, Second place votes: 7, Third place votes: 2; total = 22 Ant-Man (Scott Lang) First place votes:12, Second place votes: 3, Third place votes: 2; total = 44 Picked! Dan Hibiki First place votes: 0, Second place votes: 2, Third place votes: 5; total = 9 Kingpin (II) First place votes: 4, Second place votes: 6, Third place votes: 6; total = 30
45th round of nominations:
Spoiler Alert!
Dex-Starr First place votes: 7, Second place votes: 5, Third place votes: 4; total = 35 A.R.G.U.S. Agents First place votes: 6, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 7; total = 33 Unknown Soldier First place votes: 3, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 3; total = 20 Cyborg (II) First place votes: 6, Second place votes: 7, Third place votes: 4; total = 36 Picked!
44th round of Nominations:
Spoiler Alert!
Iron-Spider First place votes: 2, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 4; total = 17 Dex-Starr First place votes: 6, Second place votes: 10, Third place votes: 3; total = 41 Cyborg (II) First place votes: 4, Second place votes: 5, Third place votes: 7; total = 29 Magik First place votes: 6, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 4; total = 30 Captain Britain First place votes: 10, Second place votes: 5, Third place votes: 6; total = 46 Picked! Blue Devil First place votes: 1, Second place votes: 1, Third place votes: 5; total = 10
43rd round of Nominations:
Spoiler Alert!
Dex-Starr First place votes: 6, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 7; total = 33 Cyborg (II) First place votes: 4, Second place votes: 7, Third place votes: 2; total = 28 Magik First place votes: 4, Second place votes: 5, Third place votes: 7; total = 29 Vermin First place votes: 10, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 3; total = 41 Picked!
42nd round of Nominations:
Spoiler Alert!
Cheshire First place votes: 3, Second place votes: 1, Third place votes: 3; total = 14 Kang (II) First place votes: 5, Second place votes: 7, Third place votes: 4; total = 33 Picked! Cyborg (II) First place votes: 4, Second place votes: 1, Third place votes: 3; total = 17 Magik First place votes: 2, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 6; total = 20 Dex-Starr First place votes: 3, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 0; total = 17 Vermin First place votes: 7, Second place votes: 2, Third place votes: 3; total = 28 Miss Martian First place votes: 0, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 4; total = 12
41st round of Nominations:
Spoiler Alert!
Martian Manhunter (II) First place votes: 7, Second place votes: 6, Third place votes: 6; total = 41 Picked! Cheshire First place votes: 5, Second place votes: 7, Third place votes: 3; total = 32 Vermin First place votes: 7, Second place votes: 6, Third place votes: 2; total = 35 ARGUS Agents First place votes: 4, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 7; total = 26 Kang (II) First place votes: 4, Second place votes: 5, Third place votes: 9; total = 31
40th round of Nominations:
Spoiler Alert!
Kang (II) First place votes: 5, Second place votes: 3, Third place votes: 6; total = 27 ARGUS Agents First place votes: 2, Second place votes: 2, Third place votes: 3; total = 13 Miss Martian First place votes: 4, Second place votes: 2, Third place votes: 3; total = 19 Jungle Terrain First place votes: 3, Second place votes: 0, Third place votes: 3; total = 12 Vermin First place votes: 4, Second place votes: 5, Third place votes: 1; total = 23 Meggan First place votes: 3, Second place votes: 10, Third place votes: 5; total = 34 Picked! Spike First place votes: 3, Second place votes: 2, Third place votes: 3; total = 16 Dex-Starr First place votes: 3, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 2; total = 19
39th round of nominations:
Spoiler Alert!
Vermin First place votes: 6, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 3; total = 29 Miss Martian First place votes: 5, Second place votes: 2, Third place votes: 5; total = 24 Jungle Terrain First place votes: 1, Second place votes: 2, Third place votes: 6; total = 13 A.R.G.U.S. Agents First place votes: 4, Second place votes: 6, Third place votes: 5; total = 29 Iron-Spider First place votes: 2, Second place votes: 2, Third place votes: 2; total = 12 Iron Man(Space Suit) First place votes: 2, Second place votes: 0, Third place votes: 1; total=7 Firestorm First place votes: 7, Second place votes: 10, Third place votes: 3; total = 44 Picked!
38th round of nominations:
Spoiler Alert!
Mera First place votes: 8, Second place votes: 6, Third place votes: 9; total = 45 Picked! Spike First place votes: 2, Second place votes: 6, Third place votes: 3; total = 21 Unknown Soldier First place votes: 2, Second place votes: 2, Third place votes: 2; total = 12 Vermin First place votes: 2, Second place votes: 5, Third place votes: 3; total = 19 Atlas First place votes: 2, Second place votes: 5, Third place votes: 4; total = 20 Jungle Terrain First place votes: 4, Second place votes: 2, Third place votes: 1; total = 16 Kang (II) First place votes: 7, Second place votes: 4, Third place votes: 3; total = 32 Miss Martian First place votes: 5, Second place votes: 1, Third place votes: 5; total = 22
Iron Spider Votes: 1,1,2,1,1,3,2,2,2,2,3,3,1,1,1,2 WT: 36 Jungle Terrain Votes: 2,3,1,3,1 WT: 10 Beta Ray Bill Votes: 1,1,2,1,1,2,2,2,1,3,2,3,1,1,2,1,1,1 WT: 44 Picked! Living Mummy Votes: 3,3,2,3,3,3,3,2,2,3,3 WT: 14 Red Lantern: Mera Votes: 3,2,2,3,2,2,3,2,2,3 WT: 16 Iron Man (Space Suit) Votes: 3,2,1,3,1,2 WT: 12 Judge Fire Votes: 2,1,3,3,1,1,3,1,3,3 WT: 19 Mera Votes: 1,2,1,1,3,3,1,2,2,2,1,3,3 WT: 27 Cheshire Votes: 3,3,2,1,2,1,2 WT: 14 Azazel Votes: 3,3 WT: 2 N'Astirh Votes: 1,2,1,2,1,1,1,1 WT: 22 Sin Votes: 2,3,3,2 WT: 6 Batman (III) - Vetoed by the Heroes. Hela - Vetoed by the Heroes. Zzzax - Vetoed by the Heroes. Power Girl - Vetoed by the Heroes.
Wong Votes: 1,3,1,2,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,2,1,1,2,1 WT: 46 Ulik Votes: 3,2 WT: 3 Utility Glyph: Bat Glider Votes: 3,2,1,3,1,1,1,3,2 WT: 19 Jungle Tree Votes: 2,2,3,1,3,3,2,2,3 WT: 15 Dr. Sivana Votes: 2,3,3,2,3,2,1,3,1 WT: 16 Iron Spider Votes: 1,3,2,2,1,3,2,2,3,3,3,2,1,3,3 WT: 26 N'astirh Votes: 2,3,1,3,1,2,2,3,2,1,1,2 WT: 29 Judge Death Votes: 1,1,2,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,1,1,3,2,1,1,3,2,2,2,3,1,2 WT: 50 Picked! Red Sonja Votes: 1,1,3,3,1,3 WT: 12 Iron Man (Space MK 1) Votes: 2,2,3,3,2,2,2,1,3,1 WT: 19 Sin Votes: 3,1,2,2,3,2 WT: 11 Ch'od - Withdrawn due to Sidekick ineligibility. Black Tom Cassidy - Withdrawn due to Sidekick ineligibility. Hawkeye (Kate Bishop) - Withdrawn due to Sidekick ineligibility. Rover - Withdrawn due to Sidekick ineligibility. Anti-Venom - Withdrawn due to ibechief's departure. Darkstar - Withdrawn due to ibechief's departure. Thorbuster - Ineligible due to Scapemage's promotion.
The official thread for Public Design Nomination and Voting. Here we will nominate the best designs from the Public Design thread and vote to see which one will be the next C3G design! This thread is open to everyone, not just official C3G members. Let us know what you want to see!
Rules:
1. Anyone can nominate but just one nomination per person. Please provide a link to a post containing the nominated design.
2. An eligible design is a design by a C3G Hero, Former Hero, Sidekick or Ally who has tested in the last month and will not be running concurrent public designs.
3. After nominations are finished, the C3G Heroes will review the designs and have the right to veto any nomination. Nominations may be limited to only 8 designs in a round.
4. After nominations, designs will be pitted against each other head-to-head until a winner is crowned.
---------------
Yeah, no problems at all nominating yourself!
I would have nominated some of yours, Scape, but I don't know who any of them are.
tcglkn
August 27th, 2011 12:32 PM
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations
Do Heroes get nominations? :D
Margloth
August 27th, 2011 01:09 PM
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations
This is a great idea. :up: We might want to have a running tab in the OP. And do noms expire after a design is picked? Or do they continue to rack up nominations?
I'll have to look through some stuff here. Off the top of my head, I like Zauriel, AYP's barrel, I know quozl had some neat stuff, and johnny's stuff is always good...
...oh man, maybe this ain't gonna be any easier! :lol:
Lord Pyre
August 27th, 2011 01:12 PM
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations
I should say that I've been working on some updates to Spoiler, but I haven't posted them yet. Catgirl's pretty much ready, though. I'm revamping Hood's Cloak of Dormammu, also, come to think of it.
IAmBatman
August 27th, 2011 01:14 PM
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations
Just to be clear, quozl could you edit the initial post to let folks know how the nomination and selection process will be ran here? This should be all about letting the public have a lot more say in what the public works on (Heroes would have veto rights to ensure the direction of the project stays on course, but otherwise we want you guys to have a lot more ownership).
Scapemage
August 27th, 2011 01:16 PM
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations
I think that placing a limit of 8 nominations per design slot would be good, so that we don't get too overboard nominating and have too much to vote on.
I'd also say renominating each time a slot is near ready would be a good idea (but not when both of the slots are near ready, we can vote for the 2 that will win without having to restart, for example now). We get new designs all the time, and if an old design is good enough, it should be nominated again to show it.
Griffin
August 27th, 2011 01:16 PM
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations
I don't know if it has been said or understood, but heroes will maintain the ability to say yes or no to the design. That is something that we discuss in the sanctum.
And no, if you're wondering LP and Johnny did not hack into my account and post this. :p
Lord Pyre
August 27th, 2011 01:20 PM
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations
I'm waiting on Onomatapoeia, there's a comic coming out supposedly this year that will most likely show his actual powers and backstory a bit more, so once that's done we can more accurately work on him.
I'm excited for Hood, though! :)
IAmBatman
August 27th, 2011 01:25 PM
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scapemage
(Post 1469443)
I think that placing a limit of 8 nominations per design slot would be good, so that we don't get too overboard nominating and have too much to vote on.
I'd also say renominating each time a slot is near ready would be a good idea (but not when both of the slots are near ready, we can vote for the 2 that will win without having to restart, for example now). We get new designs all the time, and if an old design is good enough, it should be nominated again to show it.
To make things easier on voting, perhaps we should only allow one nomination per poster and only vote on things that receive a certain minimum number of nominations?