Public Design Workshop 2.0

[Yodaking]

I thought the plan was to do draftable trick arrow akin to draftable spells. Instead of needing Magical Affinity to cast the spell, you must have the Archer keyword in order to use the trick arrow.

Also, I kind of like the idea of the explosive arrow reducing the base range.

[Lord Zed]

These trick arrows are so fun. I love the idea of being able to kit out the archers in a unique way.

[IAmBatman]

I think the question is how to interpret a one shot that stays in use (i.e. multiple grapples) since one shots are designed to be used and then removed.

[Arch-vile]

Tornado's idea of having a One-Shot that gives you an item makes the most sense to me.

NAME = GRAPPLE ARROWS
UNIQUENESS = COMMON ONE SHOT
TYPE = ARROW

POINTS =

GRAPPLE ARROWS
During setup, remove this One Shot from the game to equip this figure with a Grapple Arrow item.

PUBLISHER:
REQUIREMENTS: Archer
KEYWORDS:

But personally, I kinda like Arrow one shots all being single use.

[MrNobody]

One option could just be making them single-use then letting specific designs enable reuses. That'd be pretty close to how we handle Spells.

[IAmBatman]

Originally Posted by MrNobody

One option could just be making them single-use then letting specific designs enable reuses. That'd be pretty close to how we handle Spells.

I like that. Ideally we could avoid the baggage of having to bring in two separate cards to use it.

[Tornado]

Was thinking something along that line.
Not sure if the grapple arrow is more of a Green Arrow thing but could give a bonus like Batarangs but in this case GA does not discard Grapple Arrow after use.

Multi-Shot

[IAmBatman]

Hmm, maybe could just be a one shot like the rest but with a line on it to not discard it after use? Like just have that on the card itself since any archer should be able to do that, probably.

[Phantom Fighter]

Originally Posted by IAmBatman

Hmm, maybe could just be a one shot like the rest but with a line on it to not discard it after use? Like just have that on the card itself since any archer should be able to do that, probably.

If we added a line like this, is there something else needed to indicate only one hero has access to the grappling arrow? For instance if my team includes Green Arrow and Speedy, would they then both be able to use this over and over when drafting only one?

[IAmBatman]

Good question. Probably doable. One to mull over. Might be worth getting a few of the more slam dunk ones done first before worrying too much about perfecting the wording here, though.

[Phantom Fighter]

What is the proper procedure for the other three to move forward? Do I post a reply with any wording changes to my original post so that it shows it was changed after some discussion OR do I edit my original post which is in page 6 or 7 of this thread?

[IAmBatman]

To lead a C3G public design, you would need to be an Ally and make a formal request to do so and have it approved by the Heroes. I believe you would also need to have earned a certain number of points via playtesting (which is the best way to get involved in the project if you have design ambitions).