Winter Custom Competition Poll - Congrats Arch-vile

[Dr.Goomonkey]

Without further ado, here are the entries for the grand return of the QC3. We didn't get a lot of entries this time around, but we did get some good ones.

Vote for your favorite before the poll closes, and remember if you entered that you must vote for an entry that is not yours. Good luck everyone! Glad to see these knights with some meat on their bones (and bones to begin with).

Congratulations @Arch-vile
Reborn Knights

Bio:

Spoiler Alert!

The Phantom Knights have served Utgar faithfully throughout many battles, but their existence is a hollow one, stuck for eternity without the ability to feel a cold winter's air, or taste a delicious feast. Thus, the most successful of the Phantom Knights were rewarded with new bodies by Utgar. The so-called Reborn Knights now lead their brethren into battle, where the Phantom Knights fight even more ferociously in order to earn Utgar's favor.

@GeberalRolando 's
Knights of Golron

@cmgames 's
Gonfalon Knights

Bio:

Spoiler Alert!

The Gonfalon Knights recognize the value of a banner in heartening the troops. They have made it their personal mission to eliminate the Flag Bearers of the enemy whenever possible.

@kolakoski 's
Jardinian Knights

Bio:

Spoiler Alert!

The Jardinian Knights, a Druidic order, blessed with a special affinity for nature, are charged with its care and protection.

 

[Yodaking]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

Some really good stuff here!

 

[cmgames]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

I like both 'Tormented Soul' and 'Rewarded With New Life'. They both reinforce the link between these Knights and the Phantom Knights.

~Z

 

[Yodaking]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

Yeah, the Reborn Knights are a really cool add on to the Phantom Knights. They were my 2nd place choice, in part because they are only playable when also drafting the Phantom Knights. I went with the Gonfalon Knights for my pick, in large part because I have always really liked Einar's Samurai squads, the Einar Imperium, the Gladiators, the Ninja of the North Wind, and the 10th Foot. So getting an aura boost for those specific units means I'd get to play a bunch of different armies featuring my favorite squads. Then the Capture the Flag power is one that won't come into play all that often, but would be a fun way to utilize the squad when a flag bearer is in play.

I'd consider doing something similar that only boosted Einar Unique Squads as a way to get the Samurai into more games. Maybe a new card for the Einar Samurai Flag Bearer? He could boost Einar's Unique Squad figures in clear sight of the flag for one power. Then for a 2nd power, bring in Samurai/Ninja reinforcements by returning lost Einar Unique Squad figures to play.

 

[Arch-vile]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

Knights of Golron are very cool. I like how you can mix-and-match squads with them.

 

[yamissflash]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

I like the knights of Golron. The design I was working on but missed the deadline was like them but not nearly as good. Also the only one that keeps the righteous trait mentioned in the PK’s bio.

 

[Dr.Goomonkey]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

Just one day left to make your voice heard! Less than 24 hours, in fact...

It's a close race, too. If you've been holding out you might just get to choose the winner here at the last minute.

 

[lefton4ya]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

IMHO all but Jardinian Knights are way too OP

• Gonfalon Knights is like having 3 Raelins and Taelords for only 60 points! Even if just for Einar is still way, way too OP.
• Knights of Golron is actually kind of cool, just has too many game-breaking powers, and need a lot better wording. However I really to like the Tormented Soul power.
• Reborn Knights - I actually think this is the most thematic of the options, I just think it is way too OP and both the point values are way low and defense is too high. Basically an opponent has to destroy all of these units last but until thin you have 6 attacks each turn. Make 4 defense AND 140-180 points would be more like it, and at high points games this is still OP.

So again Jardinian Knights it is. Nice little 60 point filler that can do some serious damage to heroes.

 

[cmgames]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

@lefton4ya - I think that the Gonfalon Knights are actually appropriately costed, or at least close

Their 'aura' only covers 18 hexes each, whereas Taelord (+1 attack) covers 60 hexes, and new Rae (+1 defense) covers 126 hexes. If you calculate points/aura-hex/life for each of them and add them together (.79) and multiply that times the 18 hexes x 3 figures, you still come to a price point lower than 60 (~43). Now figure that they each have 1 additional defense over Tae & Rae, and the fact that their 'aura' only affects Einar and only squads, I think 60 points is not an unreasonable cost.

Of course, only repeated playtesting ( ) will ensure that we work out the true 'correct' cost.

~Z

 

[Dr.Goomonkey]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

CONGRATULATIONS ARCH-VILE!!!​

You showed just what the Phantom Knights always were before they were phantom knights, by showing us what they could be after they stopped being phantom knights anymore... Hmm, well done matching the level of contravity I set up reopening these.

Excellent entries all around, and of course an honorable mention to @GeneralRolando for very nearly sneaking away the victory at the last minute, with their very first entry in these
contests.

Thanks to everyone who entered, voted, or just enjoyed looking over the cards! Looking forward to seeing what you all come up with in the spring.

 

[lefton4ya]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

Congratulations @Arch-vile. I apologize that I misread the card when voting in that I thought "Rewarded With New Life" replaced the figure the Phantom Knight killed with a Reborn Night, which is why I thought this power and unit was way too OP. If I read it properly I would have definitely voted for this unit.

@cmgames for Gonfalon Knights I did think about the aura but IMHO having split units makes it potentially more spread out. One think I did not think though though is the units each have one life so that makes it less valuable than hero as easier to kill first. Maybe 60 or maybe 80 points is more accurate, but you are right would need playtesting with the 10th or Roman Legion

 

[Myriadite]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

It was quite tough voting on only one.

 

[Arch-vile]

Re: Winter Custom Competition Poll - VOTE BY 3/8

Thanks for running the contest! It was a fun prompt and I loved seeing how others approach the same prompt.