What's new
  • Welcome to the Heroscapers 2.0 site! We've still got some dust to clear and adjustments to make, including launching a new front page, but we hope you enjoy the improvements to the site. Please post your feedback and any issues you encounter in this thread.

C3G Public Design Nominations - TIEBREAKER

MrNobody

MrNobody

Just A Head
Welcome to the C3G Public Design Nominations Thread!

AL9nZEV2OslzdPcFBrETuQA2_CTAkLUfpRSICBTO7FTo0QIsRc1cz_LBXvfXdgummuS-kXd-25N8PLJSZ3dTOhNpsEKVVJ_laY6led47o-prHftd1yWe9j_k_Fc7GsIAJrnhMlMOvsZNfjgD3iIJKrE-DFY=s820-no

Most recent winner: TIE (All For One and Hired Hit story card)​


What is this thread for?

C3G holds a fan vote on a regular basis to determine units to be designed in public, known as the Public Design. When a the previous winner of this thread hits Public Playtesting, we will begin taking nominations for the next Public Design in this thread.

This thread is open to everyone to nominate or vote, not just official C3G members. Let us know what you want to see!


How do I nominate a design?

When nominations are open for an upcoming round of voting, anyone may nominate a single design by posting a link to the design. The best place to find designs is the Public Design Workshop. Any design from a C3G Hero (past or present), Sidekick, or Ally is valid for nomination so long as the designer has completed at least one public playtest* between the announcement of the most recent winner of this poll and the closing of first round nominations. You may not nominate your own design, spread the love. :)

*See the Playtesting Sign-Up thread for more information.


How do I vote for my favorite design?

After the Heroes have approved the nominations, voting will begin! Voting will occur in a single-elimination bracket. Everyone can vote, whether they are a member of C3G or not.

Once the final round of voting concludes, the winner will be decided! The designer may immediately begin a new design thread for that unit. Designs created through Public Design Nominations do not cost any Reward Points.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
- Most Recent Nomination Round

TIEBREAKER ROUND [Ends 12/05]​

- Previous Nomination Rounds
Spoiler Alert!
http://www.heroscapers.com/community/showpost.php?p=1665468&postcount=7991
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

Previous OP:
Spoiler Alert!


---------------

Yeah, no problems at all nominating yourself!

I would have nominated some of yours, Scape, but I don't know who any of them are.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

Do Heroes get nominations? :D
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

This is a great idea. :up: We might want to have a running tab in the OP. And do noms expire after a design is picked? Or do they continue to rack up nominations?

I'll have to look through some stuff here. Off the top of my head, I like Zauriel, AYP's barrel, I know quozl had some neat stuff, and johnny's stuff is always good...

...oh man, maybe this ain't gonna be any easier! :lol:
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

I should say that I've been working on some updates to Spoiler, but I haven't posted them yet. Catgirl's pretty much ready, though. I'm revamping Hood's Cloak of Dormammu, also, come to think of it.
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

Just to be clear, quozl could you edit the initial post to let folks know how the nomination and selection process will be ran here? This should be all about letting the public have a lot more say in what the public works on (Heroes would have veto rights to ensure the direction of the project stays on course, but otherwise we want you guys to have a lot more ownership).
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

I think that placing a limit of 8 nominations per design slot would be good, so that we don't get too overboard nominating and have too much to vote on.

I'd also say renominating each time a slot is near ready would be a good idea (but not when both of the slots are near ready, we can vote for the 2 that will win without having to restart, for example now). We get new designs all the time, and if an old design is good enough, it should be nominated again to show it.
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

I don't know if it has been said or understood, but heroes will maintain the ability to say yes or no to the design. That is something that we discuss in the sanctum.



EDIT:
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

In list of preference:
  1. Johnny's Reverend Stryker
  2. LP's The Hood
  3. LP's Onamatepia (Or however that's spelled)
  4. Johnny's AIM Troopers
  5. LEIV's Onslaught
And no, if you're wondering LP and Johnny did not hack into my account and post this. :p
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

I'm waiting on Onomatapoeia, there's a comic coming out supposedly this year that will most likely show his actual powers and backstory a bit more, so once that's done we can more accurately work on him.

I'm excited for Hood, though! :)
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

Scapemage said:
I think that placing a limit of 8 nominations per design slot would be good, so that we don't get too overboard nominating and have too much to vote on.

I'd also say renominating each time a slot is near ready would be a good idea (but not when both of the slots are near ready, we can vote for the 2 that will win without having to restart, for example now). We get new designs all the time, and if an old design is good enough, it should be nominated again to show it.
Click to expand...

To make things easier on voting, perhaps we should only allow one nomination per poster and only vote on things that receive a certain minimum number of nominations?
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

IAmBatman said:
Scapemage said:
I think that placing a limit of 8 nominations per design slot would be good, so that we don't get too overboard nominating and have too much to vote on.

I'd also say renominating each time a slot is near ready would be a good idea (but not when both of the slots are near ready, we can vote for the 2 that will win without having to restart, for example now). We get new designs all the time, and if an old design is good enough, it should be nominated again to show it.
Click to expand...

To make things easier on voting, perhaps we should only allow one nomination per poster and only vote on things that receive a certain minimum number of nominations?
Click to expand...
Well, 1 nomination per poster limits us to ~10 nominations, if heroes don't nominate. Then let's say the minimum is 3 nominations, likely very very few designs will get 3 nominations. Maybe a minimum of 3 nominations (maybe 4?) and every poster can nominate just 2 designs.
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

Well no reason Heroes and even non-members can't nominate if they like, IMO. :) We could always do one nomination and a minimum of 2 nominations to vote on it.
Or your way could work also. As long as we have a clear direction, I'm happy.
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

I think this is actually a great idea.
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

Heh. Where'd you come from? :p
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

OK, here's how I think it's supposed to go. We all nominate what we like. Then I put up a poll of all the nominations and we all vote for who like best. Then the top vote-getter gets to be the next design!

However, Heroes will always have veto power. And they are allowed to nominate and vote just like everyone else.

Sound good?
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

Works for me. :) There are probably going to be a ton of nominations to vote through, but if you can keep up with it, no worries!
 
Re: C3G Public Design Nominations

Looks like a poll can have a maximum of 10 so we'll need to take the top 10 nominations. Also, please link to what you're nominating!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top