Unit Debates List REVIVED - 74 Added - Laglor vs Gothlok!

[lefton4ya]

Much love goes out to @MegaSilver and his original debates list, I will try to live up to it well.

NOTE: The first three are located on the Competitive Armies Discussion. The rest are located on the Official Units Forum.

The following other people's rankings and should be taken into consideration, but also don't leave out subjectivity as these people are not authoritative in your personal views on the units.

• Classic Heroscape Power Rankings, originally by @spider_poison , at one point by @MKSentinel , now by @Jexik .
• Orc's Power Rankings by @OrcElfArmyOne
• C3V/SoV-inclusive Power Rankings by @dok
• Cleon's VC Unit Tier List by @Cleon
• Unit Battle Royal 2016, 2015, 2014, 2011, 2010, 2009

If you have any questions or comments about these debates, or have an idea for a debate, either PM me or post them here. But I cannot guarantee they will be used immediately, if ever, though they will be taken into consideration. I will attempt to add about one or twice a month, but all new debates will have polls open indefinitely. Now your comments and votes may take C3V/SoV into consideration.

Recent debates:

Unit Debate #73 Deathreavers vs Raelin the Kyrie Warrior - AKA Rats vs Bacon!
Who is the Defensive unit?

Unit Debate # 74 Laglor vs Gothlok - AKA Vydar vs Valkrill Flagbearers
Who is the 2nd best Flagbearer?

All Past Debates:

Spoiler Alert!

Unit Debate #1 -- Capuan Gladiators Vs. Knights of Weston -N/A

Unit Debate #2 -- Minutemen Vs. Militia -TIE

Unit Debate #3 -- Valguard Vs. Parmenio -Valguard Won

Unit Debate #4 -- Brave Arrow Vs. Migol Ironwill -Migol Ironwill Won

Unit Debate #5 -- Templar Cavalry Vs. Grok Riders -Templar Cavalry Won

SPECIAL EDITON Unit Debate #6 -- Brutus Vs. Baron Tobrand -N/A

Unit Debate #7 -- Marro Drones Vs. Marro Dividers - Drones barely won

Unit Debate #8 -- Aubrien Archers Vs. Tagawa Samurai Archers - AA won by large margin

Unit Debate #9 -- Raelin (ROTV) Vs. Raelin (SOTM) - First Won by Large Margin

Unit Debate #10 -- Grimnak Vs. Tornak -Grimnak Won by Large Margin

Unit Debate #11 -- Alastair MacDirk Vs. Sir Denrick -MacDirk By Large Margin

SOULBORG SPECIAL Unit Debate #12 -- 'Crons Vs. 'Trons -'Trons by small Margin

By Knight of Feylund: Unit Debate #13 -- Kato Vs. Spartacus -N/A

Unit Debate #14 -- Anubian Wolves Vs. Wolves of Badru -AW won-slim

Unit Debate #15 -- Nilfhiem Vs. Braxas -Nilf won

Unit Debate #16 -- Heavy Gruts Vs. Axegrinders - Heavy Gruts

Unit Debate #17 -- Cyprien & Sonya Vs. Iskra & Rechets -Cyprien, of course

Unit Debate #18 -- Taelord & Minions Vs. Concan & Setinels -Taelord

Unit Debate #19 -- Marrden Hounds Vs. Deathstalkers -Marrden Hounds

Unit Debate #20 -- Krav Maga Agents Vs. Nakita Agents -KMA, duh!

Unit Debate #21 -- Spider-Man Vs. Venom -Venom? Why?

Unit Debate #22 -- Su-Bak-Na Vs. Tor-Kul-Na -TKN

Unit Debate #23 -- Isamu Vs. Marcu -Isamu

Unit Debate #24 -- Kaemon Awa Vs. Major Q10 -Q10 by 4 points

Unit Debate #25 -- Spiders Vs. Nagrubs -Grubs by double

Unit Debate #26 -- Finn Vs. Thorgrim -Finn won

Unit Debate #27 -- Johnny "Shotgun" Vs. James Murphy Murphy greatly.

Unit Debate #28 -- Atlaga Vs. Marcus -Marcus by 10 points

Unit Debate #29 -- Ashigaru Vs. Romans -Romans Barely

Unit Debate #30 -- Dzu-Teh Vs. Obsidian Guards -Dzu-Teh, duh

Unit Debate #31 -- Zelrig Vs. Major Q9 -Q9, sadly

Unit Debate #32 -- Nerak Vs. Me-Burq-Sa -MBS greatly

Unit Debate #33 -- Sir Hawthorne Vs. Sir Denrick -Sir Hawthorne

Unit Debate #34 -- Elite Onyx Vipers Vs. Kozuke Samurai -Samu, sadly

By Old Rough and Ready: Unit Debate #35 -- Drake (RotV) Vs. Drake (SotM) -SotM

Unit Debate #36 -- Quasatch Hunters Vs. Granite Guardians GG large marign

Unit Debate #37 -- Knights Vs. Dwarves -Dwarves by slim margin

Unit Debate #38 -- Stingers Vs. British - Stinger by 7 pts.

Unit Debate #39 -- Zelrig Vs. Braxas -Braxas, sadly.

Unit Debate #40 -- Special Edition! -- The Valkyrie Generals -N/A

Unit Debate #41 -- Charos Vs. Captain America -Capt. America.

Unit Debate #42 -- Krug Vs. Fen Hydra -Unit Royal 2009 Winner will always win.

Unit Debate #43 -- Syvarris Vs. Brandis Skyhunter -Syvarris, duh!

Unit Debate #44 -- Sir Gilbert Vs. Ornak -Sir Gilbert

Unit Debate #45 -- Rats vs Goblins -Rats forever.

Unit Debate #46 -- Othkurik vs. Deathwalker 9000 -The Black Dragon

Unit Debate #47 -- The Kyrie Squads - Minions again

Unit Debate #48 -- Mohicans vs. Aubriens -Aubriens by close margin.

Unit Debate #49 -- Migol Vs. Mogrimm -Forgehammer Strike's Ahead

Unit Debate #50 -- Runa Vs. Sudema - killercactus won most of us over

Unit Debate #51 -- Wyrmlings vs. Elementals -Wyrmlings by small margin

Unit Debate #52 -- Heavy Gruts Vs. Death Chasers of Thesk Gruts greatly.

Unit Debate #53 -- Anubian Wolves vs. Warforged Soldiers -Tied!

Unit Debate #54 -- Venoc Vipers vs. Marro Drones -Vipers!

Unit Debate #55 -- The Wyrmlings -Blacky took the lead.

Unit Debate #56 -- Agent Carr vs. Tandros Kreel Carr's too cool for Tandros

Unit Debate #57 -- Drow Chainfighter vs. Sahuagin Raider -Drow pulled ahead.

Unit Debate #58 -- 4th Mass vs Marro Stingers -Mass moves ahead.

Unit Debate #59 -- Othkurik vs. Moltenclaw -Moltenclaw wins.

Unit Debate #60 -- Blastatrons vs. Resistance Fighters -Blastatrons

Unit Debate #61 -- Hatamoto Taro vs Deathwalker 7000 -DW7K won

Unit Debate #62 -- Eltahale vs. Frost Giant of Mohr -Eltahale

Unit Debate #63 -- Laglor vs. Sir Gilbert -Sir Gilbert

Unit Debate #64 -- Me-Burq-Sa vs. Marro Warriors -Marro Warriors

Unit Debate #65 -- Incredible Hulks! Effectively Tied

Unit Debate #66 -- Captain Americans!C3G pulls ahead!

Unit Debate #67 -- Jotun vs Fen Hydra Fen Hydra Wins Easily

Unit Debate #68 -- Snipers vs Agents - Microcorp stealths their way to advantage.

Unit Debate # 69 Arrow Gruts vs Blade Gruts - Still close.

Unit Debate #70 Capt. John Varan vs Myrddin - Captain John had your Purple Hearts

Unit Debate #71 Nilfheim vs Quahon - Nilfheim overwhelmingly won.

Unit Debate #72 Kantono Daishi vs Tomoe Gozen - Deadlocked

Unit Debate #73 Deathreavers vs Raelin the Kyrie Warrior - Raelin showed no mercy to the Rats

Unit Debate # 74 Laglor vs Gothlok

[lefton4ya]

Unit Debate # 69 Arrow Gruts vs Blade Gruts is still growing strong, with some hot chatter back and forth. Vote and particiapate in discussion if you haven't.

However time for the first VC Customs (C3V & SoV) Debate. In light of this week's Sacrificial Holidays - Good Friday/Easter and Passover (Ramadan is next week), let us vote on the best unit who willingly sacrifices themselves for your other units:

Unit Debate #70 Capt. John Varan vs Myrddin

Also, looking for some advice on the next debates, as @MegaSilver always did.

[lefton4ya]

Still looking for some advice on the next debates, as @MegaSilver always did. Please vote on the last couple if you haven't, but time for a new debate:

Unit Debate #71 Nilfheim vs Quahon

Who is the best Special Attack dragon?

[brandonwiker]

Forgive me if I wasn't supposed to post here, not entirely sure what you mean by advice, but here is my two cents for potential debates:

-Q9 vs Vulcanmech Incendiborgs?

-New Valkrill flagbearer vs Ornak/Vydar FB/Gilbert? (Gilbert might be too good to be beaten, though...)

[lefton4ya]

Thanks @brandonwiker for suggestions - I'll do next time. @MegaSilver will be proud of this poll though - the two highest rated units in the game square off:

Unit Debate #73 Deathreavers vs Raelin the Kyrie Warrior - AKA Rats vs Bacon!
Who is the best Defensive unit? I sense some heavy debate coming on this one.