DropBox for Site Improvement Ideas

[Killometer]

If we're having an informal vote, I say keep it.


I've always given a clear explanation and signed my neg reps and never received a retaliatory neg rep, as best as I can tell. Maybe just lucky, or maybe the recepients thought I justified myself sufficiently.


I also see neg rep and reporting posts as serving two different purposes, and don't think one replaces the other. I feel like reporting is for posts that should be deleted or for things that might require other administative intervention, while neg rep is a tool for personal member-to-member suggestions about improving posting habits and thereby keeping the quality of the community interaction here high.

[Grim]

Keep it.

The first bulleted RULE in the 2nd post at
https://www.heroscapers.com/communit...ad.php?t=27265
is "DO NOT WHINE" about Rep in public posts or PM's. Sounds good to me.

[Rÿchean]

I agree with grim. I invite the entire community to neg rep this post IF they don’t like me agreeing with grim.

[Alexandros]

Dump it. That rule is so old, heroscape was on shelves. I've not received (or given) negative rep and I'm not concerned, but anything that applies so much negative pressure that newcomers don't want to continue using the site is worth abandoning imo.

[Lord Pyre]

Please remove the negrep. Keep positive, I don’t care. It’s anonymous cyber bullied locked behind a paywall. Just think about younger members here, I know that if I went back in time to when I first joined, I’d I got a few negreps I’d probably never want to be here anymore. It literally doesn’t add anything positive to the community, due to the fact that it’s a NEGATIVE feature by design.

[Alexandros]

Originally Posted by Dad_Scaper

The upvote comment space is very important. I hadn't anticipated that we would be considering abandoning it. If this point is under serious consideration, please let us know, so we can have that conversation seriously.

Thank you.

I am not at all in favor of abandoning positive rep.

[Agent Minivann]

Rather than just replace positive rep with a comment upvote, I would prefer having a visual count of times a post has been positive repped while keeping positive rep.

[Tornado]

Originally Posted by Lord Pyre

Please remove the negrep. Keep positive, I don’t care. It’s anonymous cyber bullied locked behind a paywall. Just think about younger members here, I know that if I went back in time to when I first joined, I’d I got a few negreps I’d probably never want to be here anymore. It literally doesn’t add anything positive to the community, due to the fact that it’s a NEGATIVE feature by design.

Sure. When you put it that way...

[AMIS]

If you remove the negative you almost have to remove the positive or positive rep means less IMHO.

[caps]

I propose a new Age of Annihilation subforum be added. All "meta" threads concerning Age of Annihilation could be moved there, and it could have a subforum for discussing proxies (not 3d-printed ones, since those are currently not allowed on this site) as well as a subforum for "books" for the cards (per @Dad_Scaper 's post here).

[Dad_Scaper]

Originally Posted by caps

I propose a new Age of Annihilation subforum be added. All "meta" threads concerning Age of Annihilation could be moved there, and it could have a subforum for discussing proxies (not 3d-printed ones, since those are currently not allowed on this site) as well as a subforum for "books" for the cards (per @Dad_Scaper 's post here).

I agree. There's a lot to unpack there. How will these designs be incorporated into the existing game?

[Dysole]

Where would you want it to be placed?

~Dysole, curiously