The Book of Katana (Outsiders)

[Soundwarp SG-1]

B, don't dig Fighter/Warrior

[FreshFoods]

I was cool with A, but no problems with B

[Splash]

I like B or no immunity depending on: how many characters are already out that would make sense having that training with a sword and how many would be carded in the future?

edit: If it is something others would be able to understand and counter then neat idea, but otherwise with other Fighters, people with kung fu, or whoever it would also make sense they could counter Swift Strike or something, so now that I think about it it comes across that Iaijutsu would be more easily counterable than all the other stealth and fighting ninja/samurai moves, which doesn't make too much sense personally. So leaning no immunity I guess.

[Arkham]

Don’t like it referencing itself like MD unless people think this is going to be used often enough, which I seriously doubt. Small trinket text that’s pretty pointless/very rarely comes up is something I’m hoping we do less of, personally.

I don’t think I’ll be suggesting someone use a power I had planned for an LD again given how this has turned out. May just go with something else for Suicide Squad Katana, so I wouldn’t mind if you changed the name to whatever else you like and choose the option you like best.

[IAmBatman]

I mean, unless people ignored your LD, the conversation would just happen there instead of here. It’s not like I’m driving any of the concerns.

[IAmBatman]

OK. I think I’ve arrived at this:

There’s no immunity inclusion that’s not going to annoy someone. So I’m just going to cut it.

Does it cut off future design space some? Yes. But, honestly, after reflecting, it’s not a power we want stacking a whole bunch anyway, so that’s actually positive. In addition, as LP pointed out, there’s already a similar but less powerful version under a generic name that can be reuses.

So this route makes the most sense to me.

[IAmBatman]

SP updated for art. @Arkham please let me know if there’s anything you need on my end.

[Lord Pyre]

[Soundwarp SG-1]

I'm really not worried about cutting off random other hypothetical people from having a power that we don't really want a bunch of copies of, especially when there's already a 'generic' version (plus like three other versions of this power). So no restriction is my preference.

[Arkham]

Originally Posted by IAmBatman

I mean, unless people ignored your LD, the conversation would just happen there instead of here. It’s not like I’m driving any of the concerns.

I was just teasing, hence the and .

[IAmBatman]

Originally Posted by Arkham

I was just teasing, hence the and .

Heh. Fair enough. Now make me a card so I can start Hawkman!

[Arkham]

They're up