HELP US NOW PLEASE! (we're in the middle of a game!)

[K/H_Addict]

does anyone have height advantage?







Sniper is mine, Sentinel is PoF

Mods, feel free to merge this with castle rule discussion after i get an answer. It's kinda crucial, so i need to be able to find it

[LilNewbie]

No, since that ladder rung should be the same height as the space. Variances in map building or placement of the ladder could cause it not to line up correctly but it should be considered the same level as the walkway.

Newb.

[toddrew]

Nope, same level.

[hextr1p]

No.

That said, if you can't get an answer soon enough, just go the "roll off" route like the rulebook says.

Take turns rolling a d20, and whoever rolls higher wins the debate.

[K/H_Addict]

shanks foe the quick respones


(pof talkin here. IM WINING!!!!!!)

[toddrew]

Originally Posted by LilNewbie

No, since that ladder rung should be the same height as the space. Variances in map building or placement of the ladder could cause it not to line up correctly but it should be considered the same level as the walkway.

Newb.

Yeah, if the ladder segment ended at the level that the Sentinel is on (instead of beginning, as it does), then the Sentinel would have height advantage as the sniper would be one level lower - ladder segements being 2 levels altogether.

[happyjosiah]

Yeah i'm not sure I agree. I mean, ladder rungs are two levels high. And the way it lines up, if you build a thing that is 9 levels tall, you need 10 levels of ladder (5 pieces). In this case, the ladder figure is higher than the ground figure.
If you build something 10 levels tall, you will also use 10 levels of ladder (5 pieces). In this case, the ladder figure's base will technically BE lower.

SOOOOOOO....
are we saying in example one, ladder gets height and in example two they are considered even?

[LilNewbie]

Well, from the picture it appears to be a standard built castle wall which from the base to the upper platform is 11 levels high. It takes 6 ladder pieces to create a ladder that will reach the upper platform. The base clips (rungs) on each ladder piece fall almost in the middle of the ladder piece. If lined up correctly and place correctly on the map the top rung will be level with the upper platform. I added the sentence above about variances since the bottom ladder piece might not be placed properly in the gutter portion of the hex or the ladder may not be exactly lined up but that shouldn't constitute a bonus.

Newb.

[K/H_Addict]

well, that particular ladder was i believe only 5 levels high, as it is going from level 12 to level 21, so it had to over lap it by a bit. When looking at it, it looks like the bases or on the same level, so we would have played it that no one has HA anyways.

[netherspirit]

Originally Posted by K/H_Addict

well, that particular ladder was i believe only 5 levels high...

So it was five rungs, not five levels. Each rung is 2 levels. Very important distinction.

[K/H_Addict]

that's what i meant. I calrified it in the next sentence, so unles UD was reading it, it should have been common sense.