Quote:
Originally Posted by R˙chean
Quote:
Originally Posted by Grungebob
I would prefer to use software but there are logistic problems as noted. I would also prefer to minimize some trends in gameplay that are not fair such as stalling. If somebody's playstyle includes stalling, then I don't think it is a bad thing for them to change their style, especially if they are eating up too much of the clock and gaining an advantage by doing so.
|
I reiterate, I don't think that is a tactic that was being used. Stalling means you are knowingly taking longer with your turns than you normally do. This isn't what was happening. Players got upset because they lost and found something to complain about. The continued assertion that any player purposely went from normal playing mode to slow playing mode is a perception from players who lost; players who had a vested interest in the outcome. I say again: I didn't see anyone nor did I play anyone that purposely slowed down or sped up. In addition, in the 14 tournaments and 64 tournament games I have played I have yet to see this. (stalling when ahead on points)
Two sides to every coin, the person on the losing end is the one complaining. Did anyone that won complain that their opponent took too long? Probably not.
All PD does is change the possibilty; it doesn't remove it.
|
I was on the losing end of my match with R˙chean and we were headed to PD with time running out. It caused me to make some moves that I wouldn't normally make to try and swing the point differential. These moves ultimately cost me the game.
That said, I have two points....
1. I never felt like either one of us were stalling or playing the clock. The nature of the armies we had were conducive to taking more time to play. I had to move 8 figures per turn and he had to scatter 2 rats after every time I attacked. All of these extra moves made our game move along a little slower. Some armies just take longer to play and I don't think you should be punished for this. I didn't hear any accusations of stalling in any of the games I observed.
2. Maybe we could make the games longer for the second day? I am not sure how much time, but at least the SE games might not be decided by the clock. I know Rev and I could have used an extra 15 minutes and I would have loved to get 15 more minutes against R˙chean.