Battlefields of Marvel (BoM) Discussion Thread

[spidysox]

Well, looks like I need to put some votes out there.

Although it has already been defeated, I am also going to vote no to the current version of "under the el" (with an eye towards a revamped version) the map is so close to being great, it just needs that final bit of tweaking to get it where it needs to be. I love the theme of the map and look forward to the updated version.

I am going to say yes for accepting "close quarters combat" for review. This map has the potential that we are looking for. I am a little concerned with the starting zones, but that is what playtesting is for. I look forward to giving this one a go.

I am also going to say yes for reviewing "hurricane lobby". I believe this map deserves it's due process before suggesting any changes. It, much like "close quarters combat" has a lot of potential.

I am however going to have to say no to reviewing "devestated building v.5". Although the premise is a good one, the map just does not have the theme and look that we are going for in this project.


edit: 700th post!


Current Status:
Updated: 1/3/09
BoM seal bieng reviewed
BoM seal by Vydar is the man
YES:5 (peteparkerh, The Silver Surfer, Spidysox, ET86, stumpy_man); NO:0 (); Pending:1 (Ugly-Caco)

**ACCEPTED**

Maps Currently being reviewed:
Under the "EL" by Jodokast
YES = 1 (Ugly-Caco); NO = 4 (Peteparkerh, ET86, Silver Surfer, spidysox); Pending = 1 (Stumpy_man)

**DEFEATED** -Pending a remake-


Maps pending acceptance for review:

Close Quarters Combat by ~ET86
YES = 3 (Silver Surfer, stumpy_man, spidysox); NO = 0 ();Pending = 2 (Ugly-Caco, Peteparkerh)

*ET86 removed from review process per map creator


Hurricane Lobby by Ugly-Caco
YES = 2 (stumpy_man, spidysox); NO = 2 (Silver Surfer, ET86);Pending = 1(Peteparkerh)

*Ugly-Caco removed from review process per map creator



Devastated Building V5 by Sup3rS0n1c
YES = 0 (); NO = 1 (spidysox);Pending = 5 ( stumpy_man, Peteparkerh, ET86, Silver Surfer, Ugly-Caco)

[stumpy_man]

I think I voted YES to Devastated building spidy.

[Vydar_XLIII]

Pete update the front page please.

Current Status:
Updated: 1/3/09


Maps pending acceptance for review:

Close Quarters Combat by ~ET86
YES = 3 (Silver Surfer, stumpy_man, spidysox); NO = 0 ();Pending = 2 (Ugly-Caco, Peteparkerh)

*ET86 removed from review process per map creator


Hurricane Lobby by Ugly-Caco
YES = 2 (stumpy_man, spidysox); NO = 2 (Silver Surfer, ET86);Pending = 1(Peteparkerh)

*Ugly-Caco removed from review process per map creator



Devastated Building V5 by Sup3rS0n1c
YES = 1 (stumpy_man); NO = 1 (spidysox);Pending = 4 ( Peteparkerh, ET86, Silver Surfer, Ugly-Caco)

[joe5joe7]

isn't close quarters accepted for review?

[Vydar_XLIII]

I think so but it's a judge's place to say so not mine.

-Vitm

[spidysox]

Originally Posted by joe5joe7

isn't close quarters accepted for review?

Not yet. We need 75% approval to review a map. As of right now we have 60%.

Just so everynoe knows, peteparkerh is away for his anniversary so I am sure he is not able to get to a computer very often to update things here. I am sure he will do so when he can.

[nyys]

Originally Posted by spidysox

Just so everynoe knows, peteparkerh is away for his anniversary so I am sure he is not able to get to a computer very often to update things here. I am sure he will do so when he can.

Someone needs to teach Mr parkerh about priorities.

[spidysox]

Originally Posted by nyys

Someone needs to teach Mr parkerh about priorities.

I think she did!

[Sup3rS0n1c]

Originally Posted by joe5joe7

isn't close quarters accepted for review?

No, but Hurricane Lobby is rejected.

[joe5joe7]

Originally Posted by spidysox

I think she did!

no, she taught him the wrong priorities

[EternalThanos86]

To clarify from the by-laws, a map only needs a majority vote to be accepted for review and then a super-majority for acceptance into the BoM.

Originally Posted by peteparkerh

SECTION 2: How maps are judged
Maps nominated for consideration will go through the following process after a majority of acceptance votes by the judges:
...
8. Maps that receive a super-majority of 75%of the Council will be formatted and given the Battlefields of Marvel Seal of Approval.

As of right now, Close Quarters Combat has enough votes to be considered, "Under Review" and Hurricane Lobby has NOT been rejected until peteparkerh casts the deciding vote.

[Ty the Awasome]

Hey guys, sorry for interupting in here. Just wanted to get a quick post in. I've been a silent watcher so far, as I felt that the community wouldn't support this enough to make it work. However, I believe I am wrong, and I love what's going on here. Keep up the good work! Some of these maps are amazing (the bridge being my favorite so far).