For fight #1, I'll pick your guys (P1) because the rats will nab at least 1 or 2 glyphs which can be helpful while also possibly tying up some figures in the process. With Q9 in the mix, I think it's a done deal.
For fight #2, I'll also pick you to win. Minions are tough lil' buggers along with Jotun. Though I think this one will come down to the match-up between Jotun and Charos.