Brunak vs Carr

[BRUNAK]

My favorite Brunak or Carr :starwars:

[johnny139]

They have two very different uses. Though, actually, they're quite similar. Carr is a range unit that, when worst comes to worst, can really kick some ass. Brunak is a ferry for important figures that, when worst comes to worst, can also kick some ass. But I really don't know which I like better.

[dragonfire9788]

Probaly Brunak.

[ninthdoc]

Carr rocks the house. I agree with johnny139, Brunak is a fairy. :twisted:

[monkeyfish]

Brunak

[GForce3062]

Agent Carr bows down to Brunak



---< Agent Carr :bowdown: :twisted: <--- Brunak

[hi1hi1hi1hi1]

Carr all the way.

[GIR]

They have two very different uses. Though, actually, they're quite similar. Carr is a range unit that, when worst comes to worst, can really kick some ass. Brunak is a ferry for important figures that, when worst comes to worst, can also kick some ass. But I really don't know which I like better.

Totally agree with you!

[Uprising]

No one has had much luck with Carr in our house. Brunak has single handedly cleared large portions of the board alone on more than one occasion. As a matter of fact, next game we have I'm gonna break that big dunce out and rock n' roll.

[War Solves Everything]

I'd have to say Brunak

[tmacdagreat]

Agent Carr. I'm racist against red people.

[ninthdoc]

I'm a huge fan of AC. markwars was over the other night and played him against me. His comment was, "Now I see why you like him so much."

[GForce3062]

Actually, now that I've thought about it and looked at both of the figures stats, I would pick Agent Carr to win in a one on one match against Brunak. I think AC could kill Brunak faster since it's 6 vs. 7 against Brunak's attack: 4 vs. 4. Also, Agent Carr has range, and the sweet 'Disengage, Ghost Walk' duo. But in a large battle, like 750+ I would pick Brunak because he seems like a 'team player'. This is gonna bug me for a long time because I don't know which I think is better. But as of right now, I'm leaning a little towards..... Brunak. But only by a little.

[Sargent_Drake_8]

Actually, now that I've thought about it and looked at both of the figures stats, I would pick Agent Carr to win in a one on one match against Brunak. I think AC could kill Brunak faster since it's 6 vs. 7 against Brunak's attack: 4 vs. 4. Also, Agent Carr has range, and the sweet 'Disengage, Ghost Walk' duo. But in a large battle, like 750+ I would pick Brunak because he seems like a 'team player'. This is gonna bug me for a long time because I don't know which I think is better. But as of right now, I'm leaning a little towards..... Brunak. But only by a little.

Just a little...maybe about ten points...What?

[GForce3062]

Actually, now that I've thought about it and looked at both of the figures stats, I would pick Agent Carr to win in a one on one match against Brunak. I think AC could kill Brunak faster since it's 6 vs. 7 against Brunak's attack: 4 vs. 4. Also, Agent Carr has range, and the sweet 'Disengage, Ghost Walk' duo. But in a large battle, like 750+ I would pick Brunak because he seems like a 'team player'. This is gonna bug me for a long time because I don't know which I think is better. But as of right now, I'm leaning a little towards..... Brunak. But only by a little.

Just a little...maybe about ten points...What?

What I mean is I favor Brunak over AC by only a little. Sorry if that sentence was a little 'fuzzy'.

[Sargent_Drake_8]

Actually, now that I've thought about it and looked at both of the figures stats, I would pick Agent Carr to win in a one on one match against Brunak. I think AC could kill Brunak faster since it's 6 vs. 7 against Brunak's attack: 4 vs. 4. Also, Agent Carr has range, and the sweet 'Disengage, Ghost Walk' duo. But in a large battle, like 750+ I would pick Brunak because he seems like a 'team player'. This is gonna bug me for a long time because I don't know which I think is better. But as of right now, I'm leaning a little towards..... Brunak. But only by a little.

Just a little...maybe about ten points...What?

What I mean is I favor Brunak over AC by only a little. Sorry if that sentence was a little 'fuzzy'.

Yeah, I know, that's what I was saying. You like Brunak more, but only by a little bit. Well guess what, he's a little bit more expensive, so has been rated a little bit better, and...and...ah, forget it.

[GForce3062]

Actually, now that I've thought about it and looked at both of the figures stats, I would pick Agent Carr to win in a one on one match against Brunak. I think AC could kill Brunak faster since it's 6 vs. 7 against Brunak's attack: 4 vs. 4. Also, Agent Carr has range, and the sweet 'Disengage, Ghost Walk' duo. But in a large battle, like 750+ I would pick Brunak because he seems like a 'team player'. This is gonna bug me for a long time because I don't know which I think is better. But as of right now, I'm leaning a little towards..... Brunak. But only by a little.

Just a little...maybe about ten points...What?

What I mean is I favor Brunak over AC by only a little. Sorry if that sentence was a little 'fuzzy'.

Yeah, I know, that's what I was saying. You like Brunak more, but only by a little bit. Well guess what, he's a little bit more expensive, so has been rated a little bit better, and...and...ah, forget it.

I see what you're saying, so you don't have to bother explaining it. GAH! I don't know who I like better! Brunak! Or Agent Carr! GAH!!!

[darkclown789]

Brunak is a coin-flip unit, like the Deathwalkers. He can die on a whim if he whiff's a defense roll, although generally hard to kill. Brunak all the way for me!

Carr is pwnt by range...

Darkclown

[Ugly-Caco]

Agent Carr bows down to Brunak



---< Agent Carr :bowdown: :twisted: <--- Brunak
This is accurate. Well...not quite. Can you make that smiley darker and the other one red?

[GIR]

Brunak can die in one hit. Carr in two.

Carr also has some range, better mobility, and an awesome attack of 6!

[GForce3062]

Brunak can die in one hit. Carr in two.

Carr also has some range, better mobility, and an awesome attack of 6!

If he doesn't die by the time he engages someone. :wink:

[Silver1327]

Agent Carr. Brunak is a great for Carrying ability but Carr I like better because of his Range/Sword of Reckoning. That and his Disengage and Ghost Walk for a cheap price.

[Snotwalker 8000]

Wow... This is actually one of the few good thought-provoking "is unit X or unit Y better" threads. Good question to ponder!

Both have awesome abilitiess and strengths, but I'd have to lean toward Brunak being the better choice, due to the carry ability.

Just like with the arrow gruts always needing to be considered in light of their strength in bonding with Krug and/or Mimring, Brunak always needs to be considered in reference to how brutish he becomes when carrying around Raelin. Brunak's base defense of 7 is formidable, but is truly intimidating when he snags Raelin and drags her with, pumping up to 9 defense!

I know, I know, some will say we're just comparing the base stats and abilities of Carr and Brunak alone, but with a carry ability, I don't think that's possible. Carr is built to be a lone assassin, with Ghost Walk and Disengage and Sword of Reckoning, breaking through the ranks to throw the smackdown on his chosen target. THAT is his strength.

Brunak's strength can only be considered when he's fully using his abilites as well, in this case, the carry ability. Brunaks low life doesn't matter as much when he's rolling at least 9 of those blue babies. He truly becomes a tank with attitude in that case.

PLUS, we can't leave out the fact that Brunak has a Special Attack, while Carr doesn't. SA's are becoming more and more important in the game with all of the new defensive abilities against normal attacks coming out. Not to mention all the new Samurai!

Both Carr and Brunak are solid choices, but Brunak get's my vote.

[GForce3062]

Now I know who I like more! Last night, I played three games with PoF and in the last game, I chose Brunak AND Agent Carr just to see who would do more damage. Although Brunak did take out his points worth, Agent Carr killed nearly triple his points worth. First, he killed Nilfheim in two hits with his 'Sword of Reckoning(6+1 for height) Then he went on and defended an attack from Sgt. Drake and went on to kill him in one hit! He took out 285 points! 185 of them coming from Nilfheim! This guy really is the bomb.

[The Super Atheist]

Look, brunak has that special attack, does not succumb to hot lava death, and can carry someone, like AGENT CARR.

[Aldin]

Welcome to the boards, Silver1327!

On behalf of our metallic and numeric community I extend to you a laurel and a hearty handshake.

As a new member, you can begin your journey on the path to the fellowship, praise and respect of your Heroscapers peers by checking out this announcement: http://heroscapers.com/community/showthread.php?t=6970

I gotta go with Brunak here if only because he is almost always a synergistic unit in any army. Carr mostly sits around waiting for order markers when I play him.

~Aldin, who notes Brunak is a Carr top carrier

[Renesis]

Just by looking at the cards one might choose Carr b/c his stats rock. 6 attack, 4defense, and good specials always looks good, but he is a none bonding hero that can only make one attack per turn. That is his weakness along with many other heroes. I think of Carr as a hero assassin. Send him out mid-late game to kill your opponents bamf. Other than that he always gets smacked around by squads with decent move. I agree with Aldin in that he ends up sitting around most of the game, and if you try to bring him out early he may kill a few but he will bit the dust and your opponent could have most of their army mobilized.

Brunak is completely different. He is better in almost every way, and IMO he has what should be looked for when drafting a hero. Sure he doesn't bond but he can carry (more bang with your move markers), and more importantly he has a special that allows him to kill more than one figure a turn. Besides that he is a large figure (no lucky rolls with Braxis, Sudema, etc.) with great defense for surviving against 4attack or less. Brunak may loose one on one with Carr, but in almost any other circumstance he is better. Brunak is more of a squad killa, and everyone knows that squads usually dominate the board.

Word to my brotha big red :thumbsup:

[Jexik]

Why don't you just use both?

Brunak carries him, cuts down some scrubs, and then Agent Carr makes a beeline for what you actually want to kill.

[GoBigorGoHome]

From my experiences Brunak is far better than Carr. Carr always dies quickly when my family plays due to his low life and weak defense. As Renesis brought up, Brunak is immune to many abilities that would affect Carr although Renesis is wrong in saying that he is immune to Sudema.

[BRUNAK]

I just played them against each other. Carr had height advantage but Brunak attacked first
ROUND1.Brunak hits Carr with one wound. Carr's attack of 7 is blocked.
ROUND2.Brunak attacks with two... blocked Carr attacks with FOUR... blocked
ROUND.3Brunak attacks with all four! Carr only blocks with one and dies.
BRUNAK IS DEFENDING CHAMP!!!!!
Jexik (I think thats your name) your name is i'm talking about a one on one. Sorry for the misunderstanding.
EDIT: Oops! Sorry for that extra "your name"!

[NecroBlade]

You gotta try it more than once, though. Come back and let us know how it goes after another 9 or so tries.

[BRUNAK]

I played 'em again after 8 it was 4 to 4 then Brunak's attack got ugly and lost 4-6 but i still think he is better because there is no real way to know.

[scorpiusx]

Agent Carr can disect Brunak in a heartbeat.