Which herois best as a general?

[wimba808]

picture this senario....

All the Valkyrie generals (Utgar, Jandar, Ullar, Vydar, Einar) were somehow wiped out (i don't know how but its not that significent). which hero from each general would u consider the best replacement.

[shakey_snake]

Marcus, Duh.

[LilNewbie]

Marcus, Duh.

Why? And under what context do you mean, wimba808? Do you mean as a storyline idea or using stats from the game? I would think Drake would be a better replacement since he is familiar with more modern warfare tactics (Marcus would have to come up to speed with modern warfare tactics) and heck, Drake is an homage to Sgt. Rock. Sgt. Rock is the best! :D

This question is like the age old question of which superhero can win a fight? There isn't a perfect answer but it does bring up some interesting ideas for a story.

Newb.

[feekonea]

This is how I would do it if I understand ur question correctly...
einar= marcus
jandar= srgt drake
utgar= taelord
ullar= charos
vydar= carr

[allskulls]

This is how I would do it if I understand ur question correctly...
einar= marcus
jandar= srgt drake
utgar= taelord
ullar= charos
vydar= carr
Ditto.

Imagine Taelord drinking from the wellsprings. His cost will go up!

[feekonea]

This is how I would do it if I understand ur question correctly...
einar= marcus
jandar= srgt drake
utgar= taelord
ullar= charos
vydar= carr
Ditto.

Imagine Taelord drinking from the wellsprings. His cost will go up!

haha ya! Well, then again, he doesnt cost that much. :lol:

[wimba808]

Just as as tory line idea. Its nothing of real significance.

[wimba808]

Story line.
wrong spelling up there
opps

[Agent Minivann]

I like drake and all, but wouldn't Raelin be a better choice for Jandar? After all, Drake isn't an officer; he's a soldier.

[Jandars_Hope]

What about Ne-gok-sa? When i play i tend to unconciously pick someone to be a general and it sometimes is him!

[TAELORD FOCKER]

utgar will never die.

[allskulls]

I like drake and all, but wouldn't Raelin be a better choice for Jandar? After all, Drake isn't an officer; he's a soldier.
And Raelin is only a warrior. If it is about title then Nilfiem should take over for Jandar...he is a king.

As for Utgar, TaeFock, his demise is innevitable as good always overcomes evil. :D

[TAELORD FOCKER]

As for Utgar, TaeFock, his demise is innevitable as good always overcomes evil. :Dgood/evil. that all depends on what side you're shooting from. :twisted:

[bad_calvin]

I think Utgar is just misunderstood. How can he be responsible for the pain and suffering that his minions inflict... I swear those minions are just like rowdy teenagers. :) he tells them to knock it off, but they just don't listen.

[allskulls]

As for Utgar, TaeFock, his demise is innevitable as good always overcomes evil. :Dgood/evil. that all depends on what side you're shooting from. :twisted:Good and evil is determined before you choose sides :wink:

I think Utgar is just misunderstood. How can he be responsible for the pain and suffering that his minions inflict... I swear those minions are just like rowdy teenagers. he tells them to knock it off, but they just don't listen.Bad kids are the result of bad parenting :D

[bad_calvin]

I think Utgar is just misunderstood. How can he be responsible for the pain and suffering that his minions inflict... I swear those minions are just like rowdy teenagers. he tells them to knock it off, but they just don't listen.Bad kids are the result of bad parenting :D[/quote]

That is not 100% true. :)
Environment, and peers have a lot to do with it to. :)
In the case of Utgar.. I would have to blame it on environment. Utgar can't even have a t-party without having the guests travel through some gawd forsakin lava field...

[Turtleboy]

Mabye thats why he brought TEAlord into his army. His price was just a downside.

[allskulls]

I think Utgar is just misunderstood. How can he be responsible for the pain and suffering that his minions inflict... I swear those minions are just like rowdy teenagers. he tells them to knock it off, but they just don't listen.Bad kids are the result of bad parenting :D
That is not 100% true. :)
Environment, and peers have a lot to do with it to. :)
In the case of Utgar.. I would have to blame it on environment. Utgar can't even have a t-party without having the guests travel through some gawd forsakin lava field...
A good parent's influence will supercede environment and peers. Mistakes may be made but the parent's words will always come back to memory.

And Utgar doesn't drink tea...oh t-party...you meant toga party. :D

[Darthwewo]

I would put Valgad for Einar.He,s cool

[Shades fan]

Vydar- Otanashi
Jandar-Raelin
Utgar-Runa
Einar- Crixus[ Lucky SOB]
Ullar- Moriko
Aquilla- Sujoah
Huh mostly girls to populate Vahalla;)

[KevinWC]

This is how I would do it if I understand ur question correctly...
einar= marcus
jandar= srgt drake
utgar= taelord
ullar= charos
vydar= carr
Ditto.

Imagine Taelord drinking from the wellsprings. His cost will go up!

I think he did drink from the Wellspring after he won Utgar's "gladiator tournament."

At least if I am remembering the bios right.

[Sk8erScaper]

Jandar=Srgt. Drake
Ullar=Sonlen or Venoc Warlord
Einar=Kato Katsuro or Marcus
Vydar=???
Aquilla=Master Woo
Utgar=Nobody cause there would be a power struggle between Taelord, Mimring, Deathwalkers, Orcs, Cyprien, and the MARRO.(marro =65% of utgar's army)

[Grok General]

Utgar: Taelord
Jandar: Concan
Ullar: Saylind
Vydar: Major Q10
Einar: Kiova
Aquilla: A spider :woot:

[Elf General]

Utgar = Mimring
Ullar = Charos
Jandar = Nilfheim
Vydar = Braxas
Einar = Zelrig
Aquilla = Sujoah (break the streak lol)

[whipmaster]

Utgar would be taken over by Taelord
Einar would be take over by Kato

[Zelrig]

Utgar- Cyperian
Jandar- Sgt. Drake Alexander or Raelin
Ullar- Syvarris
Einar- Zelrig!!!! (DUR)
Vydar- Q9
Aquilla- Woo (for know)

[iceman3317]

Sonlen for Ullar

[oni]

The Ninjas would take over.

Utgar - Isamu
Jandar - Needs to get a Ninja. :(
Ullar -Moriko
Einar - Shiori
Vydar - Otonashi
Aquilla - Master Woo. Shaolin Monk is close to a Ninja.

[Nooblar]

Taking the question as a serious story issue, I'm positive Utgar would fracture. Based on the composition of his forces, I think his faction is held together by fear of the leader. Absent that leader, each commander would try to assert his own dominance.

We would at least see a split into Marro, Gruts (and friends), and Undead. Miscellaneous units could be swept up by anyone, including a fourth leader.

[Sk8erScaper]

Taking the question as a serious story issue, I'm positive Utgar would fracture. Based on the composition of his forces, I think his faction is held together by fear of the leader. Absent that leader, each commander would try to assert his own dominance.

We would at least see a split into Marro, Gruts (and friends), and Undead. Miscellaneous units could be swept up by anyone, including a fourth leader.

Isn't that what I just said?

[Einar's puppy]

:einar:= :Katsuro:
:ullar:= :ulginesh:
:vydar:= :carr:
:jandar:= :concan:
:utgar:= :taelord:
:aquilla:= :woo:

[Billtog]

http://www.heroscapers.com/community/showthread.php?t=9831

I think Kaemon and Runa would do pretty well. :)

[Nooblar]

Taking the question as a serious story issue, I'm positive Utgar would fracture. Based on the composition of his forces, I think his faction is held together by fear of the leader. Absent that leader, each commander would try to assert his own dominance.

We would at least see a split into Marro, Gruts (and friends), and Undead. Miscellaneous units could be swept up by anyone, including a fourth leader.

Isn't that what I just said?
Sorry, I must have missed your post. Yes, I definitely agree with your assessment of Utgar.

[Billtog]

Taking the question as a serious story issue, I'm positive Utgar would fracture. Based on the composition of his forces, I think his faction is held together by fear of the leader. Absent that leader, each commander would try to assert his own dominance.

We would at least see a split into Marro, Gruts (and friends), and Undead. Miscellaneous units could be swept up by anyone, including a fourth leader.

Isn't that what I just said?
Sorry, I must have missed your post. Yes, I definitely agree with your assessment of Utgar.
That's actually very insightful of both of you. The factions of marro, orcs/critters, soulborgs, and undead are clearly separated in my mind.

[Sk8erScaper]

Great minds think alike.:evil:+:evil:=?

[CupidsArt]

:einar:= :Katsuro: Einar already summoned everybody Kato knows, why wouldn't he in turn be the next in line to rule.

:ullar:= :Acolarh: They'd follow his Banner into war, why wouldn't they follow it under the winds of Diplomacy.

:vydar:= :Agent Carr: If just for no other reason than the fact that there are no real good choices for a Leader in the Vydar Armada .

:jandar:= :Concan: A Kyrie and a Leader.

:utgar:= :Ne-Gok-Sa: A Warlord who's been here longer than any of them. Sure he would be in for a real hurting from a few other Challenger (some even from his own kind), but I just see him winning out above all others.

:aquilla:= :Master Woo: The same reason as Carr.




Thank you Einar's puppy for making my post look pretty, :)

[oni]

Ah, I figured it out. Taelord takes over for Utgar. That explains why he costs so much.

[Sk8erScaper]

heh, if he can win the power struggle